College Football Playoff Rankings Prediction: Texas Climbs into Top Four, But Biggest Debate is Outside the Top 12
Be prepared to worry a lot about the teams ranked No. 18 through No. 25 this week. All of these teams – except, potentially, Boise State – will not make this year’s College Football Playoff. But they can still shape what the final 12-team bracket looks like. When looking at similar resumes, wins over teams lower in the standings can be powerful.
That’s why it will be so interesting to see how the selection committee handles a number of teams that all lost this weekend. All of these teams have fatal flaws in their resumes, which is why they won’t make the playoffs. However, there aren’t many obvious replacement options waiting in the wings, which could force the committee to keep teams in the mix.
The SEC, for example, had four teams ranked between 17th and 25th place that lost last weekend and now have four losses. No. 17 South Carolina’s 34-6 loss to Arkansas was the most egregious, even without quarterback LaNorris Sellers. Are the Gamecocks giving up completely? What about LSU, ranked No. 21 last week, which lost on a last-second touchdown to Texas?
Whether these teams stay in or drop out of the rankings could have a significant impact on whether teams like Alabama, Texas and Tennessee get back into the playoffs.
In the Big 12, Houston and Arizona both lost this weekend. Arizona is one of the best wins for Utah and BYU, while Houston is the same for BYU and Utah. If both of these teams drop out, it could improve Wake Forest’s chances of jumping BYU and/or Texas Tech.
There were very few notable results for the teams at the top of the standings last week. But there have been plenty of disruptions everywhere else, and how the committee handles them is what’s most intriguing this week.
Georgia No. 1 (9-1)
Best win: Alabama
No change in first place after Georgia crushed last week’s No. 22-ranked Missouri 48-21 on Saturday. The Bulldogs appear to be the best team in the country.
No. 2 Utah (10-0)
Best win: BYU
It took a same-day steal and some late game heroics, but Utah was able to hold off Arizona for another ranked victory.
No. 3 UCLA (10-0)
Best win: Oregon
The committee likes UCLA as the last undefeated team in the Big Ten.
No. 4 Texas (8-2)
Best win: Tennessee
This may surprise people, but Texas should be the highest-ranked two-loss team after winning a night game in Baton Rouge. The Longhorns have an impressive collection of wins (5-0 against teams ranked in the top 25 last week) and are No. 5 in record and schedule. Texas is expected to move up in the rankings.
No. 5 Alabama (8-2)
Best win: Kentucky
Alabama’s resume took a big hit this weekend when its top four wins — Kentucky, LSU, South Carolina and Mississippi State — all lost. We know this committee loves the Crimson Tide, but just like Indiana fell victim to a similar scenario last week, don’t be surprised to see Alabama slip a bit this week.
No. 6 Notre Dame (9-1)
Best win: Miami
It’s possible that Notre Dame will hold on to its fifth place finish from a week ago, but I think it will drop a spot or two due to other results.
No. 7 Indiana (9-1)
Best win: U.S.C.
It’s clear that Indiana coach Curt Cignetti isn’t a big fan of how the playoff committee has ranked his Hoosiers. He probably won’t like this ranking either, but at least Indiana moves up a few spots after the win over USC.
No. 8 Miami (9-1)
Best win: Waking up forest
The win over Wake Forest continues to age beautifully for Miami, but that’s about it on the resume for now. The Hurricanes picked up a hard-fought win over Duke, but still only have one ranked win.
No. 9 Tennessee (8-2)
Best win: Alabama
The Volunteers would be on the field today but can’t afford a mistake against a desperate LSU team this weekend in Knoxville.
No. 10 BYU (8-2)
Best win: Notre Dame
Even with Texas Tech’s victory over a 25th-ranked Oklahoma State team last week, I think BYU will remain in the lead. Texas Tech doesn’t have a win to match BYU’s win over Notre Dame.
No. 11 Texas Tech (9-1)
Best win: Houston
The Red Raiders are the last team on the field this week after their victory against Oklahoma State.
No. 12 Wake Forest (8-1)
Best win: Louisville
I could see Wake Forest jumping Texas Tech after their dominant win over SMU. However, the committee hasn’t been particularly high on the Demon Deacons, and as of now, I think they’ll be the first team out. If Wake Forest can do what it’s supposed to do over the next two weeks, it will find a path to the field.
No. 13 Iowa (8-2)
Best win: Wisconsin
Iowa continues to rise in the rankings as more teams lose. In a war of attrition, Iowa could earn a spot in the field simply by not making a mistake. The Hawkeyes’ playoff chances would jump to 30% with a win against Illinois this weekend.
No. 14 Oregon (7-3)
Best win: Ohio State
Oregon looked dead after its loss to Illinois, but somehow the Ducks feel like a viable playoff contender as we enter the home stretch of the season. Oregon ranks in the top 20 in record strength (No. 16) and schedule strength (No. 9).
No. 15 Ohio State (7-3)
Best win: Indiana
I maintain that Ohio State won’t make the playoffs, but the Buckeyes are much more involved than I expected after last week’s blowout loss to Oregon. That of course helped when the three teams ranked above OSU last week all lost last weekend.
No. 16 Boise State (7-2)
Best win: Wisconsin
While New Mexico loses to UNLV, Boise State remains in a great position to make the playoffs. If the Broncos win, they will automatically get the Group of Six bid.
No. 17 Kentucky (7-3)
Best win: LSU
A second straight loss killed Kentucky’s playoff hopes this weekend.
No. 18 Houston (7-3)
Best win: Oklahoma State
Houston’s playoff hopes ended in a devastating loss to a bad Colorado team.
No. 19 Florida (6-4)
Best win: Texas
The Gators are a confusing team but boast a resume with three season-best wins against Texas, Kentucky and Ole Miss. If the committee directly compared Florida to Oklahoma, I could see the Sooners being in that spot with their head-to-head win over the Gators.
No. 20 USC (7-3)
Best win: Ohio State
The Trojans couldn’t get it done against Indiana, and that should all but extinguish their playoff hopes. Ohio State’s win this weekend helps the recovery a bit, but USC’s playoff chances are down to 5.4 percent.
No. 21 Arizona (7-3)
Best win: Cincinnati
The Wildcats face only a slight fall after a thrilling game against No. 2 Utah that Arizona lost 40-39.
No. 22 Oklahoma (6-4)
Best win: Florida
Welcome to the rankings, Oklahoma. After back-to-back wins over Florida and Ole Miss, the Sooners are ranked in the top 25. Also considering OU’s win over Texas, the Sooners could finish even higher this week.
No. 23 Ole Miss (6-4)
Best win: Louisville
It was a disastrous weekend for the Rebels, from an SEC AD rival devastating their travel efforts (or lack thereof) to a Sunday afternoon loss that officially eliminated them from the playoffs. Ole Miss could easily — and perhaps should — fall out of the rankings entirely, but has barely held on this week.
No. 24 Louisville (7-3)
Best win: EMS
The Cardinals have won their last five games and look like the third-best team in the ACC.
No. 25 Memphis (8-2)
Best win: South Florida
The committee rarely awards G6 teams, so this may be a stretch, but the Tigers or Liberty are more deserving than the other Power Four options at this point.
Bracketing based on CFP ranking prediction
First round
December 18-19 at higher seeds
No. 12 Boise State at No. 5 Alabama
No. 11 Texas Tech at No. 6 Notre Dame
No. 10 BYU at No. 7 Indiana
No. 9 Tennessee to No. 8 Miami
Quarter-final matches
December 30 in Glendale, Arizona, January 1 in Atlanta, Arlington, Texas and Pasadena, California.
No. 1 Georgia vs. No. 8/No. Miami. 9 winner from Tennessee
No. 2 Utah vs. No. 7 Indiana/No. 10 BYU winner
No. 3 UCLA vs. No. 6 Notre Dame/No. 11 winner from Texas Tech
No. 4 Texas vs. No. 5 Alabama/No. 12 Boise State winner
Gn sports