
College football winners and losers: Big Ten’s dismal day could doom conference’s playoff hopes
The Big Ten playoff nightmare scenario is here.
The conference’s chances of putting just one team in the College Football Playoff increased significantly in Week 12, as No. 4 UCLA lost in triple overtime to Michigan, No. 8 Indiana lost its second game of the season in an overtime loss at Washington and No. 14 Ohio State’s season fell into further misery with a loss at Nebraska.
Advertisement
UCLA’s undefeated season ended with the loss to the Wolverines, but the Bruins suffered a potentially much bigger blow on the first overtime play when quarterback Ty Dieffenbach was tackled to the ground. The Bruins starter remained on the ground after the play and had to be carried off the field on a stretcher after trainers tended to him.
Dieffenbach was replaced by Madden Iamaleava, who looked a lot like a quarterback who started the season third on the team’s depth chart. Iamaleava — whose brother Nico suffered a season-ending knee injury in UCLA’s win over Oregon — is set to start against No. 18 USC in Week 13, assuming Dieffenbach is unable to play.
For now, UCLA is expected to remain in the tentative College Football Playoff field in Tuesday’s rankings. The same can’t be said for Indiana, which could fall out of the top 11 and is also now in a three-way tie with Oregon and Iowa for second place in the Big Ten.
UCLA head coach Bob Chesney speaks to an official during his team’s loss to the Michigan Wolverines.
(Sportswire Icon via Getty Images)
The Hoosiers could also be on the wrong side of the tiebreaker.
Advertisement
The Big Ten’s primary tiebreaker for ties between teams that have not played each other is record against common opponents. All three teams beat Northwestern and Michigan. Iowa beat Washington. And Oregon has Washington next week. A win there eliminates Indiana from the Big Ten title game in a three-way tie.
The four-way tie is also in play. UCLA is now 7-1 in conference play and would fall to 7-2 with a loss to USC next week.
We won’t go into more detail about tiebreakers just yet, but you get the point. The Big Ten summit could be an abject disaster. That’s not good for the conference’s playoff hopes.
If Dieffenbach is out for the season, UCLA falls to 10-2 and is on the wrong side of the Big Ten title game tiebreakers, will the committee eliminate the Bruins from the playoffs? It’s not a scenario exactly like Florida State in 2023, but there is at least some precedent for the committee to abandon a team that looks worse with a backup quarterback.
Advertisement
In a world where two-loss UCLA isn’t around in general, what’s the argument for the three-loss loser of the Big Ten title game to take the field if BYU finishes the season at 10-2 and Wake Forest or Miami are 11-2?
Curt Cignetti of the Indiana Hoosiers reacts during his team’s loss to the Washington Huskies.
(Steph Chambers via Getty Images)
The Big Ten boasted the last three national champions thanks to elite teams at the top of a conference that lacked elite depth. This year, the depth of the Big Ten may have improved, but it came at the expense of the top of the conference. No team seems capable of winning the national title.
Here are the rest of this week’s winners and losers:
Advertisement
Winners
Wake Forest: On a day when the Big Ten’s best teams struggled, Wake Forest showed why it shouldn’t be an afterthought for the postseason. The Demon Deacons outscored Georgia Tech 36-7 in the first half of a 50-29 victory. Georgia Tech’s first-half touchdown was the first time a team scored against Wake Forest in the first half since NC State more than a month ago. Quarterback Gio Lopez completed 17 of 22 passes for 324 yards and two touchdowns, while Deuce Lawrence rushed 13 times for 105 yards and Ty Clark III had 18 carries for 98 yards. The Demon Deacons should qualify for the playoffs with a win against Duke in Week 13.
Clemson: Say what you want about Dabo Swinney and how he handled Clemson’s struggles for a second straight season. But Friday night, it was clear his team hadn’t given up on the season. Until No. 3 quarterback Trent Pearman, the Tigers held Duke star running back Nate Sheppard to 116 yards on 19 carries and Blue Devils quarterback Walker Eget threw 38 times for just 149 yards. It wasn’t a pretty victory — WR Bryant Wesco threw an interception and the Tigers rushed the ball 51 times — but Clemson is now assured of a winning season.
Houston quarterback Keisean Henderson: The highly touted freshman made the first start of his career at West Virginia on Saturday and led the No. 20 Cougars to a 34-31 victory at West Virginia. Starting in place of Conner Weigman, Henderson completed 18 of 28 passes for 268 yards and a touchdown while rushing 14 times for 39 yards. Houston’s chances of making the playoffs were dashed in Week 11 with a loss at Colorado. But a 10-win season is still in play with a win over Baylor to end the regular season and a bowl win.
Advertisement
Tulane: The 2026 season was a poor follow-up to last season’s College Football Playoff blockbuster. But Will Hall’s team pulled off a massive victory against North Texas on Saturday. The Green Wave won 28-24 after falling behind 14-0 in the first quarter. Quarterback Trace Johnson completed 17 of 21 passes for 283 yards and four touchdowns, while WR Cameron Roberts had four grabs for 81 yards and two touchdowns. The victory also made the Tulane Bowl eligible and could have knocked North Texas out of the Conference USA title game.
Losers
State of Florida: Rick Stockstill’s record as FSU’s interim coach is now 2-1. The Seminoles lost 28-10 at home to NC State — a team also led by an interim coach after Dave Doeren was fired — in an absolutely lousy second-half performance. NC State scored three straight touchdowns in the final 30 minutes to turn a 10-7 halftime deficit into an 18-point victory. Quarterback Ashton Daniels threw two interceptions as the Seminoles fell to 5-6. A win against Florida is needed for a bowl game.
Advertisement
Massachusetts: This was set up perfectly for the Minutemen in Week 12. UMass entered the penultimate week of the season simply needing a win over a 1-9 Akron team to get six wins and be bowl eligible for the first time. Instead, Akron earned a 34-33 road victory. UMass allowed 379 yards on just 52 plays and was outscored 17-7 in the second half. Bowling Green (3-8) is up in Week 13. Can UMass beat the Falcons to make the playoffs?
Colorado: The Buffaloes’ dream of a bowl game is over. Colorado turned the ball over four times in a 35-28 road loss to Cincinnati. Isaac Wilson threw three picks and Quanell Farrakhan Jr. lost a fumble. The Buffs had the ball twice in the fourth quarter, but turned the ball over on downs, then Wilson threw his final interception of the game with 40 seconds left. The loss dropped Colorado to 4-7 heading into its final game of the season against UCF.
South Florida: Brian Hartline’s first season at the helm of Tampa was difficult. The Bulls are bowl eligible at 6-5, but fell to 2-5 at State with a 35-14 loss at Florida Atlantic on Saturday. It was USF’s third straight loss, falling just one game out of last place USA. USF rushed 27 times for just 45 yards and had Tulane in Week 13.
Gn sports