
‘East of Eden,’ ‘Tip Toe’ and Other Traumatic Dramas Dominated Fall TV
ANGIE HAN How was your fall, Dan? Mine turned out perfectly fine—good, even, considering the recent turning of the political tide to add to the seasonal fun of Halloween and pumpkin spice novelties.
The characters I watched, though? Phew. Television has always had sad bags, of course, but more than once in recent months I’ve found myself more bored than moved by the sheer excess of trauma – not least because it so often feels like a shortcut to an attempt at depth.
Instead of a personality, Apple Nocturnal gives its hero, ex-cop (Liev Schreiber), a dead wife, a dead child and a dead partner. The peacock The good girl opens with a murder, then a school shooting, then continues to pile on the stabbings and sexual assaults like it’s trying to win the trauma Olympics. Abuse justifies Lizzie Borden murders in Netflix series Monster. Intimidation catalyzes Carrie White’s powers in Carrie. Even robots are not safe. What is Disney+ VisionQuest otherwise a very long series of therapy sessions to unpack the grief?
I’m not saying that television avoids tragedy. One of the best shows of the fall, Starz’s British import Tiptoefocuses on a horrific anti-gay hate crime. But creator Russell T Davies also loves his characters enough to make them more than the sum of the terrible events that happen to them, making the series both less bleak than you might expect and even more devastating.
It’s just that at a certain point, misery starts to feel less moving and more…cheap. Or maybe I’m a Chris Hargensen.
DANIEL FIENBERG It’s like I’m saying, “Save the drama for your mom, but save the trauma for fall TV.” »
Yes, trauma has abounded on the small screens lately. Childhood sexual abuse motivated Cathy’s (Florence Pugh) ruthless rise to independence and power in the Netflix series. East of Eden; Negligent advisors motivated Pamela Voorhees’ (Linda Cardellini) doting mother to go on a killing spree in Peacock’s Crystal Lake; a car accident leaves the protagonist (Sam Nivola) in Hulu Fake certain that his mother (Connie Britton) has been replaced by an imposter. Somehow, even the absence of trauma could cause trauma — not that I want to spoil what made Maria Sten’s Frances Neagley a law enforcement badass in Amazon’s eponymous film. Reach spin-off.
Sometimes trauma is a clever shortcut to justify rage – usually female – and it can seem, as you note, cheap. But it’s not necessary. Tiptoe immediately tells you where the story is going, and it’s a five-hour descent into tragedy and horror, but there are moments of joy along the way – Davies It’s a sin worked the same way – and Alan Cumming and David Morrissey’s performances are sure to be among the best of the year. East of Eden allows Zoe Kazan to restore the biblical sprawl that her grandfather Elia cut from his 1955 adaptation of John Steinbeck’s novel while giving Pugh and Hoon Lee, as Chinese-American servant Lee, well-deserved showcases.
An interesting case study in how to use trauma as a triggering event without descending into misery is that of Apple. Little prophetsfrom writer-director Mackenzie Crook. The hero, played by a revelatory Pearce Quigley, has been lost since the disappearance of his girlfriend seven years ago, but the series is about friendship (Lauren Patel plays the other half of an eccentric duo), healing and the alchemical process necessary for the birth of the supernatural beings known as homunculi. The series never goes where you expect it to, casting a spell of funny weirdness that won’t work for everyone but worked for me.
HAN I think “wallowing” is the key here. There’s a difference between a story that grapples with tragedy to expand our understanding of its characters and the world they inhabit and a story that thinks a character’s sadness makes them intrinsically interesting; one that uses trauma as the beginning of a larger, more nuanced conversation and one that treats it as the final word.
If, like me, you’ve recently spent too much time watching shows that do the latter, the good news is that the antidote is readily available. I’m talking about the second season of the Netflix Inuit comedy North of the northwhich finds its deeper purpose in the sense of communion and culture which links its characters. Lead actress – and ray of sunshine in human form – Anna Lambe sets the tone. Or Paramount+ It’s getting worse and worsea British show that depicts both the dizzying pleasure and agonizing mortification of standing on the edge of true adulthood. And while I don’t know if things will actually get worse for these characters, HBO’s fantastic comedy Youth suggests, with creator/star Sharon Horgan’s characteristic honesty and hilarity, that the chaotic process of growing up within oneself continues into midlife.
It’s possible for a show to speak meaningfully about our upsetting times without descending into sorrow. Robert and Michelle King’s CBS Procedural Cupertino revolves around headline-grabbing scandals, but it’s good to see charming and capable lawyers holding fast-moving tech companies accountable for anything they break along the way.
FIENBERG Youth And It’s getting worse and worse fall into the category of feel-good and feel-good TV shows because the mortification factor in both is very high. I tried to watch everything It’s getting worse and worse in one sitting, and while I appreciate Leo Reich’s quirky, upbeat sensibility, I needed a break. Youth could almost be a counterpoint to It’s getting worse and worse title See, we told you. Luckily, Horgan is one of those people I’d watch in anything – even if she inherently makes the show “How could anyone still find me attractive?” somewhat misleading premise. Fortunately, there’s more to it than that.
Cupertino it’s almost the opposite. It’s TV that does good and bad. It’s about the impending techno-apocalypse and the encroaching horrors of AI, but unlike the wrath of Robert and Michelle King, The good fight and filled with terror Wrong, Cupertino is sunny and funny. As pessimistic as these previous Kings shows were, Cupertino is also semi-optimistic in its insistence that there are people (played, in this case, by Mike Colter and Rachel Keller) fighting, well, the good fight.
(Relative) optimism is a way for a show with seemingly dark subject matter to avoid being depressing. Do you know what else works? An aggressive plot. Two of my favorite shows returning this fall, this one from Netflix The diplomat And Black dovesare filled with murder and geopolitical disaster – but they are SO excited that no cataclysm seems permanent because the next one is fast approaching. It’s a hell of a way to not wallow.
But the best way to beat the blah is with pure, unapologetic joy, and you mentioned my favorite warm and fuzzy show, North of the north. He’s so full of heart and flooded with feeling that you could imagine him wallowing in it, which is even worse than wallowing in torment. But the show is never delicate. It’s culturally rich and deliriously hopeful, and Lambe is the purest of pure TV stars. Other Things That Make Me Smile This Fall: The Rapid Absurdity of NBC’s Shows The fall and rise of Reggie Dinkinsthe telegenic grumpiness of Paramount+’s Bill Murray reality show A course called Ireland and the wacky accents and family ties in Netflix’s squid-tastic Below. What helped you break out of traumatic ruts this fall?
HAN Ironically, HBO War! Forget the title; It’s a perfectly juicy legal drama from George Kay, the man who made a plane hijacking funny on Apple TV Divert. It follows the conflicting sides of a high-profile divorce involving a billionaire tech mogul (Dominic West) who is actually sane — making the series a fantasy on par with Amazon’s. Lord of the Rings: Rings of Power or the charming Paramount+ Avatar: Seven Havens.
I too laughed at the second season of Rise and fall of Reggie Dinkinswhich takes on its full meaning after a fragile first series in January. And I cherish the time I spend each week with the busy medical professionals and equally busy professors at NBC. St-Denis Medical and ABC Abbott Elementary Schoolrespectively; there’s something so comforting about a well-oiled comedy ensemble.
FIENBERG I haven’t yet mentioned my favorite show of the fall: the second season of Sterlin Harjo’s The truthFX’s genre-defying mystery/comedy/slice-of-life set in Oklahoma. Emmy voters ignored the first season, so in addition to Ethan Hawke at his best, the series added a rarely better Tommy Lee Jones, a perfectly cast Betty Gilpin, and more twists and philosophical twists than ever. Critics were given six episodes before the season started, and I accumulated the last two because in today’s television landscape, you never know when it will be three years before you get a new season – or if you’ll get a new season at all.
So let’s leave aside the winter TV that’s on the horizon: the return of Amy Poehler’s series! Another Pride and prejudice with zombies, but this time without zombies! The end of Emilie in Paris! – what I’m looking forward to and what I’m dreading the most is the conclusion of a great season of a series that I love. This is my trauma, and it feels good.
This story appeared in the November 18 issue of The Hollywood Reporter magazine. Click here to subscribe.
Gn entert