
“Essentially Worthless” – Disgruntled Fans Review Pikmin 4 Bombing on Switch 2

Pikmin 4 – Nintendo Switch 2 Edition + Dandori Academy is available now, bringing 4K visuals to the 2023 title as well as the new Dandori Academy mode and some cool little extras like voice controls.
We gave it a score of 7/10 in our test. It’s still good – hell, Pikmin 4’s main campaign might be the best of the bunch – but we can’t deny our disappointment with the lack of mouse controls and 60fps performance.
But if you take a look at Metacritic, you’d think Nintendo just released its worst game in years. Although the metascore sits at a commendable 83, the game’s user score is high, a lot less than 2.3. This essentially means that its average is “generally unfavorable.” Yeah.
So what’s going on?
Most people just seem unhappy with the idea of Nintendo charging for what they perceive to be a very minor upgrade over the original. It’s true that over the years many games have received free updates for newer hardware, but Nintendo has chosen to charge £7.99 / $9.99 / €9.99.
One user said:
“This Switch 2 edition is essentially worthless. At worst, it’s a spit in the face of fans of the series. $20 AUD for a bunch of recycled content and 4K visuals. They didn’t even bother to implement 60fps even though the system could certainly handle it. Such a lazy update, and yet they have the nerve to charge $20 AUD.”
Meanwhile, another user provided a slightly more measured assessment, stating:
“Dandori Academy reused the content, half of the maps so far are taken directly from the base game and the other half share the exact same layout. Also the new map on the title screen looks like an advertisement, spoils the pretty scenery, luckily it can be hidden.
“The main game also suffered, now having longer loading times than the original Switch. Every other Switch 2 edition has made them shorter, so that’s really weird. It’s not a small difference either, some have literally doubled.”
The comment on loading times is particularly interesting.
This has been pointed out elsewhere, with YouTuber “Press A!” » by publishing an analysis entitled “Pikmin 4 DLC is a disaster…” (introducing that characteristic YouTube nuance here) in which he compares the loading times of the Switch 2 edition with the original. When exiting a cave, the original took around 6 seconds to load the main environment, but the same time took over 30 seconds in the Switch 2 version.
A few people mentioned that the loading times were quite long, so we tested it ourselves. While loading into a cave takes around 6 seconds, loading took around 14-15 seconds. Not the 30+ others cite, then, but probably long enough to raise an eyebrow or two.
Pikmin 4’s user score on Switch 2 offers a stark contrast to that of Zelda: Ocarina of Time. Despite some concerns here and there regarding the game’s overall difficulty and accessibility compared to the original, Ocarina of Time has the highest user score of all time at 9.6.
We’ll be curious to see if Nintendo takes steps to improve loading times in Pikmin 4, but for what you actually get with the new content and visual improvements on Switch 2, we’d say the upgrade price is probably appropriate. This will keep us going until Pikmin 5, at least.
Gn tech