
Finance, fossil fuels and “overshooting”: six key points to remember from Cop31 | Cop31
1. Fossil fuels cannot be ignored
These negotiations failed due to the refusal of some countries to allow the mention of fossil fuels in the final text of the “coverage decision” – the “Antalya pact” – and the refusal of other countries to agree on an outcome without it.
Yet to most observers it will seem absurd that a climate conference does not address the real cause of global warming.
The EU, the UK, a handful of other rich countries and many developing countries, including the most vulnerable small islands and least developed countries, joined a loose coalition of around 130 parties on Saturday evening to demand recognition of the need to “move away from fossil fuels” in the final outcome of Cop31.
Their demands have failed, but the problem will not go away. All countries agreed to “move away from fossil fuels” at Cop28 in Dubai in 2023. This initial promise still stands and has not been repudiated, but refusing to talk about fossil fuels no longer seems a tenable position for the world’s only climate forum.
2. Financial matters
Although developing countries made up most of the 130 countries grouped in a “progressive coalition”, many of these countries did not oppose the “Antalya pact” at the final session of Cop31. For many, this was because finance was a much bigger issue than fossil fuels.
A growing number of poor countries are facing a debt crisis brought on by the Covid pandemic, inflation that has eroded their capital and increased interest on their debt, and the failure of rich countries to recognize the problem. Added to this are the impacts of extreme weather conditions, which are taking an increasingly heavy toll in this year of a supercharged El Niño.
Many spend more on addressing the impacts of global warming on agricultural yields, infrastructure and disasters than on basic budgets such as health and education. Rich countries have promised them money to help them adapt to such impacts and transition to low-carbon economies.
At Cop29 in Baku in 2024, rich countries pledged to deliver $300 billion (£229 billion) a year to the poor world by 2035 from public sources, and to facilitate an additional $1 billion in funding from private sector sources. But this money has been slow to reach the countries that need it most.
The main demands from poor countries, particularly in Africa, were to fulfill a promise made last year to triple funding for adaptation. However, they did not feel heard in their demands and were angry. “We did not come here to beg,” African ministers told the Cop.
Australia also made a strategic error in failing to mobilize financial parties at an early stage. As a developed country, Australia is required under the Paris Agreement to provide climate finance to poor countries. On several occasions, Australia brushed off questions of finance by saying “he’s not a finance cop” – this was true, but it did not go down well with developing countries where finance is literally a matter of life and death.
3. We need to talk about overcoming
Global temperatures have now risen by more than 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, and within a few years this state will likely be considered permanent unless strong action is taken. However, it was difficult to discuss it at the Cops, because the Paris agreement stipulates keeping temperatures “well below 2°C” while “continuing efforts” to limit them to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels.
The difference may not seem significant, but it is crucial: above 1.5°C, low-lying countries and islands face flooding, coral reefs die, and irreversible tipping points will begin to be triggered.
For the first time, this cop recognized and started discussing “exceeding” the 1.5°C target. There was no agreement on the way forward, but at least a start was made.
4. The presidency holds the key
Cop means “conference of the parties” and at each summit the chair will insist that it is a “party-led process” and that their role is simply to facilitate. This is a polite fiction: in reality, the presidency can make or break a cop.
For the first time, this cop had two presidencies. Both insisted the deal was working well – Chris Bowen, Australia’s chairman of the negotiations, even said he didn’t understand how single-country presidencies in the past had coped.
But when it comes to crucial negotiations with 195 countries, time is of the essence, and consulting two presidencies takes twice as long. The gaps between the first draft of the coverage decision on Monday, the second draft on Thursday and the third draft in the early hours of Sunday morning – followed by a fourth and final draft on Sunday afternoon – showed how difficult it was for the joint presidencies to coordinate quickly when necessary.
5. Electrification is vital
Pushing for renewables to replace fossil fuel power generation is decades in the making, but ultimately it is an “unstoppable” process, helped by the dramatic decline in the prices of wind power, solar panels and batteries, as well as the fossil fuel shocks of recent years, which have demonstrated how susceptible oil and gas are to supply crises and inflation.
But electricity generation accounts for only a minority of fossil fuel use – with the rest going to transport, heating and industrial uses. Unless these emissions are also decarbonized, the world will fail to reach its goal of net zero greenhouse gas emissions.
This is where electrification comes in. Electric vehicles are now almost as cheap as internal combustion engine cars, while heat pumps – some of which can also be used for cooling – have been widely adopted in some countries and electrified industrial processes are now operational. Electrification is also far more efficient than fossil fuels, meaning our energy needs could be cut in half by switching from fossil fuels to clean electricity.
Cop31 failed to agree on the goal championed by the presidencies of producing 35% of energy from electricity by 2035, but it managed to put electrification firmly on the map.
6. “Insurmountable” divisions remain
Cops work by consensus; it must be clear that almost all, if not all, countries are happy with an agreement before it can be adopted. This is not quite the same thing as unanimity: previous COP presidents have reached agreements despite a small number of objections. But this means that presidencies have to put a lot of effort into ensuring that all countries are happy before they can expect a text to be adopted.
Consensus can also be a disempowering force, producing “lowest common denominator” agreements. In the past, cops have often passed weak deals rather than let negotiations fail.
Some countries have called for reform of the COP process and the UN is slowly working on proposals. But consensus has advantages, in that an outcome produced by such painful methods is difficult to repudiate – for example, 1.5°C is now a key climate target, despite opposition to its adoption at the 2015 Paris summit.
Bowen told reporters at the end of Cop31 that “insurmountable divisions” between countries had made a deal impossible. This poses a serious question for Cop32 next year in Ethiopia. If the process is to continue – and most progressive countries want it to, as it is the only global forum dedicated to climate – these divisions must be recognized and countries must work to find common ground, well before the next COP even begins.
Gn headline