
Franklin High teen provoked physical altercation before fatal fall, new report concludes
In the minutes before a 17-year-old Franklin High student died, he punched another student and tried to forcibly kiss a female classmate, according to the Los Angeles County medical examiner’s office.
The new details add a level of nuance – and will likely spark more debate and controversy – around the campus death of Xavier Nungaray-Martinez on September 30.
Cellphone video widely shared online showed much of Xavier’s final moments. The video shows Xavier being punched multiple times in a classroom by another student, before running out and then over a fourth-floor railing as it appeared the student who punched him was quickly approaching.
Xavier’s family said he was the victim of bullying, and his death sparked calls among parents for increased security measures, including the return of school police to campuses.
But what happened before the videos was not disclosed.
According to a medical examiner’s office report obtained by The Times on Tuesday, Xavier first hit the student, then “attempted to forcibly kiss a female student,” who pushed him away.
It was then, according to the report’s “summary and opinion narrative,” that an “altercation” took place between Xavier and the student, which was “broken up” by a substitute teacher. Then Xavier ran out of the classroom, and while the other student was 25 to 30 feet away, Xavier ran toward the railing and “jumped,” the summary states.
The medical examiner’s summary does not appear to match exactly what is visible on the video. In this sequence, which begins after Xavier’s alleged provocations, the other student delivers at least seven blows while Xavier appears to be on the ground and does not fight back. Xavier later gets up and, as the teacher tries to separate them, the other student gives him another blow, knocking Xavier down again. Xavier then trips and runs away from the class, while the other student, visibly agitated, yells at him to run and shouts a racist insult at him.
Attorney Michael Carrillo, who represents Xavier’s father, questioned whether the investigator had even seen the video, calling the report a “rush to judgment.”
The report The Times obtained Tuesday also includes notes written by an investigator with the medical examiner’s office. In those documents, the investigator said he spoke with an LAPD detective who said that after Xavier tried to kiss the girl, the student he had previously punched returned him. The detective also told the investigator that some witnesses described Xavier as “acting as if he were under the influence of an unknown substance.”
Family members vehemently denied any suggestion that Xavier used drugs.
On Monday, attorneys for Xavier’s parents announced they had filed a lawsuit for damages with the Los Angeles Unified School District, alleging that it permitted unsafe conditions on the Highland Park campus and violated its legal obligations to protect students in its care.
An attorney who represents Xavier’s mother told The Times on Monday that Xavier was regularly targeted and even beaten by a group during his sophomore year. A separate complaint, filed by Xavier’s father, said the district and “its administrators knew that Xavier … was being bullied before the savage beating” and “did nothing to protect (him) from this bully or other bullies.”
The medical examiner’s summary of the incident said Xavier had a history of depression, citing the office investigator’s findings and a discussion with an LAPD detective. However, the investigator, in her account, claims that a person whose name was redacted – presumably a family member – told her that Xavier had never been diagnosed with depression and that he did not drink alcohol, smoke or use narcotics.
“The deceased was doing well in school and had good grades,” the investigator said. “Everything was normal.”
At a news conference Monday at district headquarters, Xavier’s mother watched as her attorney read a statement from her saying Xavier had a positive attitude, was actively working on a school project and was looking forward to graduating.
According to a toxicology report included in the medical examiner’s report, Xavier’s body tested “presumptive positive” for marijuana use.
The report does not directly address whether Xavier might have been high at the time of his death. People can test positive for marijuana weeks after using it. The medical examiner’s office did not immediately respond to a question from The Times on this point.
The toxicology report did not detect any other substances.
The medical examiner also determined that Xavier’s cause of death was “blunt traumatic injuries to the head and torso, and the cause of death was suicide.”
Family members disputed the suicide findings, saying they believed Xavier was fearful and perhaps disoriented and had simply made an impulsive move to escape the student who appeared to be chasing him.
Attorney Spencer Lucas, who represents Xavier’s mother, asked “who was interviewed and what evidence they reviewed that led them to this baseless conclusion of suicide. The coroner has made no analysis of the head and brain injuries he suffered in either attack versus the injuries sustained in the fall.”
Gn usa