
Goldman Sachs Admits the ‘AI Unwinding’ Has Become Something More Dangerous – and It’s Watching for 3 Significant Signs
The S&P 500 closed Friday in correction, falling 3.59% to 6,918.45 for its seventh straight loss and longest losing streak since February 2020. The Nasdaq Composite fell 5.28% and is now down more than 2% for the year. Goldman Sachs notes that the index is 12% below its Oct. 6 record, and its strategists cited the three things they would need to see before setting a floor.
Snider’s note said the selloff “expanded this week, moving from an AI unwind to a broader growth deterioration,” noting that the S&P 500 excluding AI had held up until this week and is now 6% below its high. Goldman’s basket of AI stocks is down 32% since October 6. Cyclical stocks have lagged defensives by 5 percentage points over the past 10 days.
Goldman’s note was written before Friday’s rout was fully reflected in its data. Its securities prices are valid as of November 19 and its hedge fund data runs through that date. So the question is whether Friday did what the note was looking for – things could be even worse in the markets than it admitted.

The three conditions
Goldman said any of the following would favor a bottom and recovery: news that boosts confidence in AI’s benefits, a dovish signal from the Fed, or a sharp decline in investor positioning.
Condition 1: AI gains. This is one that the market is trying to test. Investor Dan Niles told CNBC that a price war between Anthropic and OpenAI is hurting both, noting that their combined sequential revenue growth fell from 75% in the second quarter to 48% in the third, while combined losses increased from $7.9 billion to about $8.4 billion. Reuters cited a valuation of about 40 times Anthropic’s sales. An official at US bank Asset Management said the valuation “assumes years of rapid growth”. Goldman’s own outlook says AI’s outlook for 2028 and beyond “is highly uncertain.”
Condition 2: The Fed. Futures put the chance of a December hike at around 95% and the Fed will meet on December 9. Goldman economists expect hikes in December and March, sending the federal funds rate to a high of 4.25% to 4.5%. A dovish signal seems unlikely in the near future. Treasuries rallied sharply on Friday as investors sought safety, which is not the same as a Fed pivot. Philadelphia Fed President Anna Paulson said Thursday that the Fed will have to raise rates again because inflation is too high. The yield on the 10-year Treasury is close to 5%.
Condition 3: A sharp decline in investor positioning. This often marked the end of past withdrawals.
The first condition is unsatisfied to say the least. Anthropic’s historic IPO has turned into something of a referendum on the entire AI business, an unfair weight to place on a single, albeit remarkably large, company. The company raised $93.5 billion after underwriters exercised an option, surpassing SpaceX’s $85.7 billion as the largest IPO on record. Shares jumped 17% on Thursday, then gave most of it back on Friday to close at $88.91, not far from the IPO price of $83. “Anthropic faded relatively quickly,” said Robert Pavlik of Dakota Wealth. “I don’t think investors believe there’s anything wrong with the company…I think they’re just skeptical of this market.” Morgan Stanley, the underwriter responsible for stabilizing the shares, closed its support position, removing a potential pillar of support.
UBS said the debate has shifted from whether investments in AI will continue to generate enough revenue and returns for shareholders. An economist at Capital Economics wrote that the IPO’s success while other AI stocks fell shows that parts of the AI ecosystem are “no longer evolving as one,” with chipmakers Nvidia, Broadcom, Micron and AMD falling about 12% to 14%.
Nvidia’s 14% drop on Friday was its worst day in nearly two years. It lost 22.9% for the week and is down 47.5% since October 6, a loss of $2.7 trillion in market value. Reuters reported that the SEC was studying its accounting practices. Jensen Huang resigned as CEO on November 12 and CFO Colette Kress is serving as interim CEO. The VIX, Wall Street’s “fear gauge”, closed at 35.89, its highest level in 19 months.
“It’s a meltdown right now,” said Arun Sundaram of CFRA Research. David Kelly of JPMorgan Asset Management took a different view: “It’s not a deadly disease. It’s not even the flu.”
Positioning has not disappeared
Regarding the third condition, the Goldman note indicates that hedge funds have already reduced their investments. Their net leverage is the lowest since April 2025. A companion report, Snider’s Hedge Fund Trend Monitor, indicates that the long positions of the most popular hedge funds have focused on AI trading and lagged the S&P 500 by 14 percentage points over six months. This is one of the worst sequences in the 20-year history of the basket. The memo describes the hedge fund situation as “bruised and widening.”

But Goldman’s broader sentiment gauge remains above average. U.S. stock mutual funds and ETFs have raked in nearly $170 billion in the fourth quarter so far. Asset managers’ net positions in stock futures are in the 82nd percentile over the past 10 years. Goldman’s equity strategists estimate that the AI boom has lifted S&P 500 earnings 25% above trend. Goldman Research says capital spending on AI produced “about half” of this year’s profit growth.
The street is divided on whether this is the top. Capital Economics expects further declines. Goldman’s Nov. 17 outlook, written before the cut, called for 8,700 by the end of 2027. In the Nov. 20 note, its range extends from about 5,800 to 8,100 depending on whether investors regain confidence in earnings. Compared to Friday’s close, that’s down about 16% and up 17%. These percentages are my calculations, not Goldman’s.
After the S&P 500’s 22 corrections since 1980, the index returned an average of 4% over the following three months. It increased in 17 of them. E*Trade’s research is less reassuring. Of the 14 times since 1983 when the index first closed 10% or more below a record, five have become bear markets.
Gn bussni