
Google told schools to accept AI or lose search. Now 3 of the 4 largest districts are pushing back
Google gave school districts what many called an ultimatum: allow students to see AI summaries in their Google searches, or abandon Google search on school accounts altogether.
In August, Google enabled a Gemini tab in Google Classroom by default for K-12 students whose schools had already licensed its AI chatbot, Gemini. On November 3, the company reversed course by announcing that its AI tools would be disabled for K-12 student accounts, unless school administrators enable them, starting early next year. But Google has also made clear that schools that want students to have Google Search will have to accept AI Previews, the AI-generated summaries that have become familiar at the top of search results.
“Search and AI are deeply integrated,” said Chris Phillips, vice president of education at Google. The New York Timesadding that students in schools that don’t allow AI “will not have access to the search and they will see a message from their school saying it is not available.”
Many school districts have restricted or banned student use of AI, citing security and privacy concerns. They may not have expected that these restrictions would cost them the world’s most popular search engine, a trade-off that has caused information technology experts to question Google’s reasoning.
Google’s move comes as tech companies face growing legal pressure over harm to children. In March, a Los Angeles jury found Google’s Meta and YouTube negligent and determined that they failed to warn users of the dangers of their platforms. In January, Google and Character.AI, a Google-related chatbot company, agreed to settle lawsuits from families who claimed their children were harmed by its chatbots.
And earlier this month, a family sued Google, alleging that their 13-year-old daughter used Gemini on her school-provided Chromebook to plan her suicide and that Google offered its AI products to students without notifying parents or schools.
“We hear the concerns of parents and teachers about students using AI to shortcut learning, and we share the same goal: helping students learn,” a Google spokesperson said, adding that the company is testing new Gemini features to support “productive struggle” by helping students “solve problems without jumping straight to answers.”
Whether that’s enough to convince districts that have restricted AI is another question. The nation’s four largest school districts have landed in different places, both thanks to AI and Google’s decision to tie it to search.
Alphabet, Google’s parent company, did not respond Fortunerequest for comment.
Chicago: “We don’t want your Gemini”
Chicago Public Schools have held up the most. On December 22, 2025, the district began blocking student access to AI tools such as ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, and other third-party AI products. Students may only use AI-enhanced edtech tools approved by the district’s compliance process under SOPPA, the Illinois Student Data Privacy Act.
On Nov. 11, about 30 protesters gathered outside Google’s West Loop offices, chanting, “Hey Google, nice try. We don’t want your Gemini.”
In a statement to Chicago Sun-TimesA CPS spokesperson said the district is “actively exploring all options to independently remove” AI previews in Google searches.
“The District wishes to continue providing students with access to the Google search engine without the AI component. If such an arrangement cannot be reached, the District will look to other search solutions,” the spokesperson said.
New York: Chatbots Off, AI Previews Still On
New York City Public Schools, the nation’s largest district, appears to be moving in the same direction, although it hasn’t yet made a decision. On September 2, Mayor Zohran Mamdani and Schools Chancellor Kamar Samuels announced a one-year moratorium on AI for students in kindergarten through eighth grade. They also banned companion chatbots in all tiers.
After Google’s announcement, Mamdani posted on X that “Google is trying to use its monopoly power to force AI into our public schools. No company should have the power to dictate how we teach our children.”
City Council Speaker Julie Menin and Council Member Shekar Krishnan sent a letter to Google CEO Sundar Pichai asking whether Google would allow students to continue using Google Search without AI previews and, if not, why not, given that Google restricts product features for younger users, as is the case with YouTube Kids. The stakes are high: the district has about 1.3 million Chromebooks, including 500,000 assigned to students, according to the letter.
District spokeswoman Nicole Brownstein said Gothamist that officials were “contacting Google to further discuss this update” and that the district had already disabled the Gemini chatbot and AI mode on student Chromebooks. If Google doesn’t budge, the nation’s largest school district will have to choose between softening its stance or finding another search engine.
Los Angeles: District-Wide AI Block Meets Google Search
Los Angeles Unified, the nation’s second-largest district, announced Sept. 2 that it would block generative AI for students in all grades on district-provided devices for the 2026-2027 school year, a decision affecting approximately 378,000 students.
In public comment at a meeting of the district’s ad hoc Generative AI committee after Google’s announcement, Hillary Power, a parent and member of Schools Beyond Screens, called on Los Angeles Unified to continue “to formalize, expand and extend the current moratorium on student use of generative AI.”
“Google was particularly clear about its priorities when it issued a monopolistic and, frankly, pathetic ultimatum a few days ago to schools to use their AI search products or risk being excluded,” she continued.
The district asked Google for a way to disable AI summaries, according to LAistand said it was reviewing Google’s announcement and its “potential implications for schools, educators and students.”
Miami: Google’s largest school partner faces new state rules
Public schools in Miami-Dade County, the nation’s third-largest district, could be heading in a different direction.
In 2023, the district blocked AI chatbots such as ChatGPT due to concerns about cheating and misinformation, according to The New York Times. Two years later, the company reversed course and brought Gemini for Education to approximately 100,000 high school students, which was the largest deployment of AI in a U.S. school district at the time. In February, the district announced its continued collaboration with Google to give all of its high school students free access to comprehensive SAT practice exams through Gemini.
But on September 16, the Florida Board of Education voted to require public school districts and charter schools to set rules for the use of AI. Schools will also need to tell parents and guardians which AI tools students will interact with, so families can enroll their child in a tool or request a non-AI alternative. Districts have until July 1, 2027 to comply.
Miami-Dade County Public Schools did not respond to questions about how it will adapt to Google’s policy and Florida’s new rules.
This decision raises questions
Lina Khan, former chair of the Federal Trade Commission, criticized Google’s decision to link search to its AI summaries. In a November 3 article on X, she said the company was using its research monopoly to “force schools to adopt AI.”
“Several courts have found Google liable for violating antitrust laws, and this latest decision shows that it still has not been punished,” she said. “As public opposition to the use of AI in schools grows, Google is making clear that it will punish those who do not comply.”
Khan is not the only one to question whether this decision is legal. Zephyr Teachout, a professor at Fordham Law School, said she did not find Google’s claim “credible” that it cannot separate AI previews from search and that the company could be found in violation of antitrust laws governing how companies link the sale of two products.
In antitrust law, tying is when a company with significant market power requires that customers who want to buy one of its products also buy another. Google parent Alphabet is No. 5 in 2026 Fortune 500. According to the FTC, tying raises antitrust concerns when it “restricts competition without providing benefits to consumers.”
“Google has conducted searches for decades without AI, has filters that let people see results without AI summaries, and has been inconsistent in how it has responded to the linking request — simply claiming they are ‘deeply integrated’ is not a legal argument,” Teachout said. “The company has on/off controls for K-12 administrators and could have on/off controls for search and AI.”
Google has already lost a tie case. In April 2025, U.S. District Judge Leonie Brinkema ruled that Google had “deliberately acquired and maintained monopoly power” in two parts of the online advertising market and illegally linked them by pushing websites that wanted full access to its ad exchange to also use its ad server.
But the company also won a case involving AI insights. In September, U.S. District Judge Amit Mehta dismissed a lawsuit filed by Penske Media over Google’s use of its content for AI previews, finding that Penske had not plausibly demonstrated that search and AI previews were separate products.
Teachout said schools are different, pointing to “clear evidence of a distinct market demand in schools for research, separate from AI.”
Whether a court will take up such a case or agree with Teachout remains an open question. Google’s changes take effect early next year, and until then, districts will have to decide whether keeping Google Search is worth accepting the AI that comes with it.
Gn bussni