
How Demi Moore’s Identity Was Stolen by a Former Assistant
In March 2018, someone entered a FedEx office in Beverly Hills to pick up a package addressed to Demi Moore.
This person was not Moore’s assistant, even though the badge indicated otherwise. He had never met the actress and had no legitimate reason to collect her mail. But he knew the tracking number, the original shipping address and exactly what was inside the package: Moore’s American Express black card.
Over the next three weeks, he would charge nearly $170,000 to the card while Moore was in Idaho, unaware of what was happening in Los Angeles.
And the person who walked out of that FedEx office with his card was someone I knew.
David Matthew Read was not what you imagine when you hear “criminal mastermind.” Blond-haired and blue-eyed with a dimple protruding from one cheek, he was disarmingly frank, gentle and funny. We first met in 2011, when he was in his 20s and I was in my 40s. I needed help hanging curtains and a friend introduced me to him as a friend from church. Soon, David was somewhere between my part-time assistant and my best friend, helping me with everything from running errands to booking trips to preparing for parties.
It wasn’t until I gave him access to everything – including my post office box, where he collected my mail for me – that the friend who introduced us told me that David had actually been in prison a few years earlier for bank fraud.
But, the friend assured me, David was so trustworthy now that the church let him use his credit card to buy decorations for his office. And when I asked David about the fraud and the prison sentence, he was so open, so unapologetic, and so willing to admit that he had done something wrong that I immediately put his crime out of my mind.
Yet a few months into our deal, I realized that as an underemployed freelance writer, I didn’t actually need an assistant. Besides, something about David was starting to seem odd; he claimed to be able to do things he couldn’t do, and I didn’t realize it until he presented me with the “finished” result – a website, an Ikea bookcase, research – and it was so unfinished I didn’t even know what to say.
When I let him know that I no longer had work for him, he was gentle and understanding; he drove off in his orange Mitsubishi Eclipse convertible, and I thought that was the end.
And it was — until a few months later, when I got a call from Citibank telling me I owed almost $7,000 on a credit card bill. Convinced it was a mistake, I asked the representative to read the card number.
“It’s not mine,” I replied, relieved.
Oh, but it was, she explained. It was an additional card on my account, issued in the name of David Read.
As she read the list of accusations, I fell into a spiral of shame. How could I have been stupid enough to give so much access to my life to a convicted criminal?
***

Illustrated by Lincoln Agnew
I don’t remember exactly what David said when I first confronted him, just that he initially denied everything, then confessed pretty quickly. He told me he only did it because the church needed him to buy some things and, as a convicted felon, he couldn’t get a credit card. So he intercepted my credit card bill one day while collecting my mail and ordered a card in his name on my account.
When I read accusations that we both knew could not have been made against the most cowardly of churches—among others, Good Microbrew, The Abbey, Mickey’s, Hooters, Malibu Family Wines, DMH Aesthetics, and a dating site called Successful Match—he admitted that his motivation had nothing to do with the church. He just wanted a credit card and had no other way to get one.
David didn’t cry or ask for forgiveness. He calmly explained to me that he never wanted me to be financially responsible, which is why he had been paying the charges for months; he just needed time to raise the money. Eventually the friend who introduced us paid off the credit card and told David to pay it back with regular donations to their church. (David ended up leaving the church shortly after.)
And so David became a part of my past, the story of the assistant scam that I eventually forgot.
Until July 2018, when the friend who introduced us sent me a link to a ALL RIGHT! magazine article that David had done something similar to Demi Moore.
***

Illustrated by Lincoln Agnew
A few months ago, mostly out of curiosity, I decided to see if I could find David. It took about four minutes: I logged onto a public records website, entered his name, and sent an email to the four potential email addresses provided: Are you the David Read who once worked for me?
Two bounced. This is not the case.
A few minutes later, “Hi Anna, please call me,” with a phone number popped up in my inbox.
A few minutes later my cell phone rang with a message: “Is this Anna you just emailed me.”
I was surprised how easy it was to find a guy who had spent 55 months in prison. But I was even more surprised by the name and photo that appeared on my iPhone next to the text.
David Read was now Taylor Read Madison. The person I had known as a man was now living as a woman.
Three days later, I sat across from Taylor at Liberation Café in Hollywood, sharing a breakfast burrito, Alanis Morissette playing in the background. The blonde hair, blue eyes, and dimple remained, but the hair was now long and pulled into a ponytail, the nails were painted, the dimple was decorated with a touch of blush, and she wore some jewelry, including a diamond wedding ring.
Taylor felt both familiar and unfamiliar. As I watched her take a hook out of her white purse and hang it on the table before carefully placing the bag on top to keep it from lying on the floor, I couldn’t help but notice that she seemed nervous.
And of course, she had every reason to be. She also had every reason not to want to make her story public. So why was she here?
To tell this story, it helps to go back to the beginning.
***
Pennington Gap, Virginia, is the kind of place where you might expect a wife to receive hefty compensation when her husband dies of black lung.
And that’s what happened to Caroline Rhea, Taylor’s maternal grandmother. Thanks to the settlement and the fact that she was “good with credit cards” (a fact Taylor tells me without a hint of irony), Caroline was able to shower the grandchild she raised with clothes she might not have been able to afford otherwise.
“My grandmother was a little too caring,” Taylor says now. “I think she felt guilty that my mother couldn’t raise me, and so she overcompensated.” (Taylor Read Madison gave me permission to use her former name and pronouns to describe events before her transition.)
From a young age, David learned that “things” could make up for things like having a mother who couldn’t take care of himself and a father who wasn’t there. Even though David and his grandmother lived in a single-wide trailer, “people thought I lived a completely different life,” Taylor says. He helped perpetuate the illusion by getting off the bus early so the other children wouldn’t see where he lived.
The fraud started innocently enough. When David was 19 and attending Mountain Empire Community College in Big Stone Gap, Virginia, he began dating a fifty-something lawyer named Sam (not his real name) and soon moved into Sam’s three-story, six-bedroom house. After about a year, their relationship had cooled and Sam moved in with a new boyfriend. But the house was so chaotic and unstructured that instead of moving out, David simply moved into another room.
The chaos extended to Sam’s financial life. “Sam wasn’t very good with money,” Taylor says. “He was paying off his credit cards with credit cards, living way beyond his means. And he had me on all his cards.”
One day, David realized that Sam probably wouldn’t even notice if David bought a car. And so he ended up driving a 1995 Oldsmobile Aurora to Los Angeles, his pockets stuffed with about $6,000 that he had slowly accumulated by making periodic ATM withdrawals from Sam’s account.
David came to Los Angeles ostensibly to meet a guy he had been talking to online, but when he arrived and learned the guy was still living with his ex-boyfriend, he didn’t care. He had arrived in Los Angeles, the shiny place he had always wanted to come to – a place where you could completely reinvent yourself as long as you dressed the part.
“Why do you think God invented credit? For fabulous people like me.” Demi Moore (Jules) in Fire of St. Elmo
***
The Demi Moore scam was never part of the plan. This probably never would have happened if David hadn’t done a lot of meth and hung out with a bunch of druggies.
It all started when David met a guy named Ray in December 2017, and Ray told him he had access to an account that someone who had worked at Federal Express sold him. Ray explained the scheme: American Express sends all of its cards via FedEx, and with access to the FedEx backend, you can log in and route the card to any location you want.
David had stumbled upon the perfect project for a meth-using, tech-savvy guy with a history of credit card fraud: he gained access to Ray’s account, downloaded what he found into the FedEx system, and began cross-referencing cardholder names and addresses using…
Gn entert