
John Mulaney SNL: Why are we still talking about it
Season 52 was difficult to Saturday evening live. With the first five episodes hosted, in order, by a athleteA sleeping movie starA hack rightly fired shoved down viewers’ throats once again by Lorne Michaels, a underutilized emerging movie starand a charmless internet sensation reserved for audiences, the young season floundered. The writers lack the confidence to uplift the hosts in need, and the younger additions to the cast have yet to collectively demonstrate that they are ready to take on the series.
And then came John Mulaney. Delivering the season’s sixth episode last week (alongside a stunning turn from musical guest Phoebe Bridgers), Mulaney’s rising tide lifted all boats, her signature knowing comic authority supporting sketches that needed little help. My colleague Jesse Hassenger called Mulaney’s resurrection a truly disastrous season.(almost) impossible“, and I completely agree. Season 52 had gone so unpromisingly that I feared even the mighty Mulaney would succumb to creeping sweat and creative torpor. Instead, he pulled off something resembling a miracle.
Mulaney is (at least) a dual threat. Led by one of today’s most assured and hilarious stand-ups, with a character blending old-school showmanship and sly observational acumen, Mulaney’s seventh hosting gig showed what a comedian with real stagecraft can do in the live sketch arena. And as an elder Saturday evening live writer with years of intimate operational experience knowledge to draw on, Mulaney could not only contribute to the actual writing (the “Who wrote which sketch?“Reddit creates it with two broadcast sketches, his monologue and a saving of time), but, one suspects, they act as a source of inspiration/corrector simply by attending others’ bull riding sessions.
Alumni organizing concerts create a fascinating dynamic for SNL. Sometimes (see: Kristen Wiig, Jimmy Fallon), it’s largely an excuse to dig up old favorites. For the more offbeat older cast members (Bill Hader, Will Forte), the show generally leans into the host’s vibe, imbuing the A-list with flavors we didn’t realize were lacking. Unfortunately, most of the returning cast-turned-hosts are grade losers in relation to the kind of stunt casting in search of clout (*cough* Druski cough) which is increasingly suspected to be of greater concern to Michaels and NBC executives these days.
Gn entert