
Pat Forde: CFP committee made clear the rules don’t apply to Alabama
If you’ve been waiting for the College Football Playoff selection committee to transfer last week’s reasoning to this week’s rankings, we have this update: When it comes to Alabama, the rules don’t apply.
What was bad for Indiana last week isn’t a problem at all for the Crimson Tide this week. The Crimson Tide committee’s torrid love affair continues unabated. It would almost be touching if it weren’t so weird.
To recap: The Hoosiers, with a loss, fell five spots in last week’s CFP Top 25 after not playing, from No. 4 to No. 9. They were essentially fired on their day off because every Big Ten team they had faced lost — a major blow to the resume, we were told.
Then this week, Alabama’s two-loss record took bullets everywhere: Kentucky, which became the Tide’s summary victory, lost its second straight game, this one at home to Florida; South Carolina was destroyed on the road by 4-6 Arkansas; Mississippi State lost its sixth straight victory; Texas A&M lost at home to Tennessee; and LSU lost at home to Texas.
That’s right, all five SEC teams Alabama defeated lost. But guess what? No change to the Tide’s No. 3 ranking. It’s an SEC miracle.
MORE SI COLLEGE FOOTBALL: Podcasts | Forums | Newsletter | Support Challenge
Chairman Hunter Yurachek said, with a straight face, that Alabama’s strength of schedule and strength of record had not been negatively affected by the collective failure of its opponents. He also credited them for beating SEC team Vanderbilt.
“We’ve seen throughout this college football season, after a big win like Alabama’s at LSU, a team is going to disappoint and lose those games,” Yurachek said, glossing over the fact that LSU is 6-4 and now unranked. “Admittedly, Alabama didn’t do its best in Nashville and didn’t find a way to win.”
Yeah, it’s tough to do this year, winning in Nashville. Arkansas, the 13th-ranked team in the SEC, did it a month ago. North Carolina State, tied for last in the ACC, would have made it in September if not for a historic collapse on the final play.
The houndstooth solution has arrived. The path to the playoffs was paved by the snowplow parents on the committee.
After beating mighty Chattanooga on Saturday — a game against an FCS opponent that won’t materially hurt Bama’s stats, trust me — all the Tide has to do is beat Auburn on Nov. 28 to lock in a CFP bid, perhaps a top-four seed and certainly nothing worse than a home playoff opener.
They could get crushed by Georgia in the SEC Championship Game and nothing bad would happen. How do we know this? Because that’s exactly what happened last year. There were no penalties for a three-touchdown loss in Atlanta.
Meanwhile, several teams that should already be ahead of Alabama won games and stayed behind the Tide. Texas (8-2), which has the same number of losses as the Tide and clearly superior victories, comes in at No. 5. Tennessee, which beat Bama by 16 points in a game that was a second-half mismatch, fell one spot to No. 9 after a 15-point road victory.
The team that passed the Volunteers was Indiana (9-1), who beat No. 17 USC by two touchdowns. Yurachek moved away from the talk of strength of schedule and strength of record that he used to justify Alabama’s place as it related to the Hoosiers, instead noting that the improving offense has helped them advance. It appears that the criteria continue to be applied randomly.
If only we had a camera at Curt Cignetti’s Tuesday night. After his three-minute broadside before the committee Monday for perceived disrespect toward Hoosiers, the double standard applied to his team and Alabama could have resulted in fireworks from Cig’s famous recliner.

One reason why the Tide’s strength of schedule has become bulletproof could be seen at the end of the committee’s Top 25. The SEC teams will fill these spots by taking turns fighting. South Carolina (6-4) is No. 21, remaining in the rankings despite a 28-point loss to a team with a losing record. Oklahoma (6-4) is No. 22, all but absolved of a loss to unranked Michigan, 5-5. Florida (6-4) is No. 24, with each of those losses by at least 16 points. Mississippi (6-4) is No. 25, with three losses in its last four games and a Sept. 6 win over Louisville, now bolstering the Rebels’ overall resume.
“If you beat a team ranked in our Top 25, that’s big for us,” Yurachek said.
This is how DRY flavored sausage is made. The committee creates its own Top 25, then declares that playing against those teams counts more. It’s an echo chamber, a self-fulfilling prophecy.
The committee currently has eight SEC teams in the Top 25, ensuring more quality wins for the league. Meanwhile, 6-4 Big Ten teams Wisconsin, Illinois, Penn State, Northwestern, Washington and Nebraska are outside the committee’s rankings, diminishing Indiana’s wins (Northwestern, Nebraska); Iowa (Wisconsin, Washington, Northwest); Oregon (northwest, Nebraska); and Ohio State (Illinois, Northwest).
Frankly, it’s partly the Big Ten’s fault. Five of his teams have not faced a power conference opponent outside of championship games: Indiana, Nebraska, Penn State, Washington and USC. At the same time, the SEC (finally) increased its championship schedules from eight to nine games, making this discussion about strength of schedule the centerpiece of its push for more deals.
The committee is clearly listening: Yurachek scored the ninth game Tuesday night. Even if none of the SEC teams have yet played this ninth championship game.
All things considered, all four SEC teams expected to make the tournament are in position to do so. But it is Alabama’s continued support that remains this committee’s blind spot.
PODCAST: Listen Sports Illustratedthe college sports podcast, Others receive voteshosted by Pat Forde, on Apple and Spotify. Watch the show on SI’s college YouTube channel or on SI TV.
Follow
Gn sports
