
Republican who called Social Security a ‘Ponzi scheme’ proposes new financing plan
Republican Ron Johnson, who earlier this week called Social Security a “Ponzi scheme,” introduced a new bill to help resolve the program’s long-standing funding problems.
The Wisconsin senator and chairman of the Senate Budget Committee on Wednesday introduced the Stop Scaring Seniors Act, which would require the Treasury to shift money into Social Security trust funds to help pay benefits for more than 70 million Americans.
The combined funds are currently projected to run out of money in 2032, and without a solution, only 78 percent of planned benefits will be payable.
Learn more on News
His proposal comes just days after he said Fox News that Social Security was a “legal Ponzi scheme.” A Ponzi scheme is an investment fraud that uses funds from new investors to pay off existing ones. Social Security is a pay-as-you-go program that uses dedicated tax revenue from current workers to pay beneficiaries, and makes no secret of how its funds are used.
“It’s a Ponzi scheme,” Johnson said. “You can’t fix it. You just close it and hope you can get some of your money back.”
He then told a Senate Budget Committee hearing Wednesday that his comments about shutting down Social Security had been “inaccurate” and that he “is not proposing to shut down Social Security.”
News week contacted Johnson’s office for comment via email outside of normal business hours.

What’s in the bill?
Johnson’s bill, one of several recently proposed to help shore up the Social Security trust funds, proposes transferring money from the federal government’s general fund to the Old Age and Survivors Insurance trust fund once its assets become insufficient to meet monthly benefit payments.
Social security benefits are financed by dedicated payroll taxes, which finance the benefits currently paid. Any excess revenue is held in trust funds invested in special U.S. Treasury securities.
But since 2021, the program has been paying out more than it receives from those taxes, meaning trust fund reserves are being used to make payments. The Social Security Trustee’s most recent report reveals that the Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI) trust fund, which provides retirement benefits and benefits to eligible family members of deceased workers, will be depleted by the end of 2032.
At that point, benefits would be funded solely by incoming payroll taxes, triggering an automatic cut of about 22 percent unless Congress acts. The decline in funds has been attributed to the large number of baby boomers retiring in recent years and falling birth rates, meaning there are fewer workers paying taxes to meet their payment obligations.
Maya MacGuineas, chair of the nonpartisan Budget Oversight Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget (CRFB), said: News week that she disagreed with Johnson’s description that it was a Ponzi scheme.
“This is not a Ponzi scheme, but it is based on many outdated principles,” MacGuineas said. “The president was right to sound the alarm, but his new idea of financing the system with general revenues may be the worst solution ever, because it would explode the national debt.”
The CRFB predicted that the bill, if passed, could add $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years.
Fixing Social Security
Johnson’s bill is one of two bills that propose using primarily other revenue sources to support Social Security funding. Other senators and representatives from both sides have introduced bills, most of which propose raising taxes to raise revenue.
Independent Sen. Bernie Sanders and Democratic Rep. Val Hoyle have proposed the Social Security Expansion Act, which would apply payroll taxes to incomes above $250,000, as well as taxes on investment gains.
Currently, only $184,500 of income is subject to payroll taxes dedicated to Social Security. Social Security 2100, introduced in the Senate by Democratic Sen. Richard Blumenthal and in the House by Democrat John Larson over the summer, proposes similar tax increases for high earners and investment income.
A different proposal was pushed by Republican Sen. Bill Cassidy and Democratic Sen. Tim Kaine, who proposed creating a new, separate investment fund for Social Security.
“We borrow $1.5 trillion, we put it in an investment fund separate from the Social Security trust fund, we inject it into the broader economy and we allow it to grow over six decades,” Cassidy said. CBS. “At this point, that covers up to 70 percent of what we need to cover the Social Security debt.”
What happens next
The Stop Scaring Seniors Act has been referred to the Senate Finance Committee.
Ccorrection: 11/21/2026, 6:05 a.m. ET. An earlier version of this article misrepresented the time frame within which the OASI was expected to expire.
Contact Newsweek’s editor-in-chief for this story: Edward Pearcey.
Gn usa