
Republicans have worse mental health in Democratic districts, study finds
Republicans living in Democratic-dominated neighborhoods have poorer mental health than those residing in heavily Republican areas. Democrats, on the other hand, report similar levels of anxiety, depression, and loneliness regardless of the political makeup of their community. These results were published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.
Politics in the United States functions as a powerful social identity that extends beyond voting. Previous research shows that a person’s neighborhood can influence who they interact with, what they buy, and even their physical health decisions. A team of political scientists and medical researchers wanted to see if political alignment between a person and their neighbors could also be linked to psychological well-being.
The research was led by Ryan Baxter-King of the University of Nevada, Reno, alongside colleagues from Boston University, Harvard University and the University of California, Los Angeles. They used a large survey of 165,000 adults conducted between May 2020 and December 2022. Researchers combined this survey data with national voter registration records to determine the exact proportion of Democrats and Republicans in each respondent’s ZIP code.
To measure mental health, the survey used established clinical questionnaires. Depression was assessed using an eight-question scale screening for standard symptoms of major depressive disorder. Anxiety was measured using a four-item scale developed for patient-reported outcomes, and loneliness was assessed using questions about social connectedness and perceived isolation. Responses were converted to scores ranging from zero to one, with lower scores representing better mental health.
Free daily newsletter
Don’t miss the next big discovery in psychology
Every morning, PsyPost sends a short briefing on the most interesting new peer-reviewed research in psychology and neuroscience.
In their first analysis, the researchers compared individuals living in the same county but in different ZIP codes. They controlled for a variety of individual characteristics, including age, gender, household income, education and physical health. They also took into account neighborhood-level variables such as population density, average household income, and the racial composition of the community.
The team found that Democrats generally reported poorer mental health than Republicans overall. However, a Democrat’s mental health score did not change depending on whether they lived in a strongly Democratic or strongly Republican zip code. Their rates of anxiety, depression and loneliness remained relatively stable across different types of neighborhoods.
For Republicans, mental health improved as the share of Republicans in their district increased. In heavily Democratic areas, Republicans actually reported more anxiety, depression, and loneliness than Democrats living right next to them. As districts moved closer to an even split between the two parties, Republican mental health improved and then stabilized.
To refine the variables, the researchers then conducted a second analysis comparing Democrats and Republicans living in the exact same zip code. This approach filters out unmeasured neighborhood characteristics that could influence well-being. They found that as a ZIP code becomes more Republican, the mental health gap between Republicans and Democrats widens. Republicans have lower levels of depression, anxiety and loneliness than their Democratic neighbors.
The researchers also studied whether the strength of a person’s political identity played a role. They separated respondents based on whether they identified as strong partisans or weak partisans. The relationship between neighborhood politics and mental health was much greater for people who said they were strong supporters, indicating that the effect is amplified for those who care most about politics.
To understand the social dynamics at play, the team looked at survey questions asking whether people felt comfortable expressing their political views and whether they liked where they lived. Both Democrats and Republicans felt more comfortable speaking out when surrounded by like-minded neighbors. Republicans in Republican areas also reported greater access to enjoyable cultural activities than Republicans in Democratic areas.
Researchers compared the mental health impact of political mismatch to other types of neighborhood mismatch, such as being a racial minority or living in a poor area. For Republicans, being a political minority in a neighborhood had a stronger relationship with mental health than being a racial or educational minority. The association was also comparable in size to the adverse mental health consequences of high neighborhood poverty.
Sociologists and public health experts document the heavy psychological burden of living in impoverished areas. The fact that policy mismatch produces a comparable statistical effect highlights the predominant role partisanship plays in everyday life. For Democrats, however, neighborhood poverty was linked to increased loneliness, but local partisanship had no such effect.
The study observes trends across geographic areas and does not test for direct biological or social mechanisms. The researchers note that it’s unclear how exactly these neighborhood dynamics work in daily life. It could be that individuals internalize their stress when they feel out of step with the local culture.
It is also possible that communities treat political outsiders poorly. The researchers point to previous research showing that Democrats are more likely than Republicans to exclude the political outgroup in social settings, and note that their results are consistent with the possibility that Democrats treat political outsiders more poorly, which could explain why Republicans are uniquely affected by their political environment.
The study, titled “Local Partisan Context and Mental Health,” was authored by Ryan Baxter-King, Jacob R. Brown, Ryan D. Enos, Arash Naeim and Lynn Vavreck.
Gn Health