
Ron Johnson’s Social Security Plan Would Add $190 Trillion to National Debt, CRFB Says
The Social Security retirement trust fund is set to dry up in less than six years, which would result in an automatic benefit reduction of about 22 percent. Senate Budget Committee Chairman Ron Johnson has a plan to stop it: let the Treasury borrow the difference.
On Nov. 18, the Wisconsin Republican introduced a proposal the Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget calls the Stop Scaring Seniors Act. This would allow the Treasury Secretary to transfer money from the government’s general fund to the pension trust fund once its reserves are exhausted, so that beneficiaries continue to receive full checks. The CRFB estimates that this would add $190 trillion to the national debt over 75 years in inflation-adjusted terms, or 165% of GDP.
For the roughly 70 million people receiving benefits, the cut it would avoid is real money: about $500 a month for the average recipient, according to CRFB. The question is who pays instead.

Commission for a Responsible Federal Budget
“We usually say that inaction is the worst option when it comes to Social Security, but now we have discovered something even worse,” CRFB President Maya MacGuineas said in a statement. She said it was difficult to view the bill as anything other than “cynical complacency that sidesteps all the real decisions we face.”
The bill goes to the bond market
CRFB, a nonpartisan deficit advocacy group, says the greatest danger won’t be 75 years from now.
“Even just passing the legislation could spook the bond market enough to trigger financial unrest,” MacGuineas said, adding that borrowing would “almost certainly trigger a crisis.”
The group has already analyzed the numbers for this type of fix. In an analysis last November, the CRFB estimated that funding Social Security from general revenues would raise interest rates by about 2.6 percentage points compared to keeping the trust fund intact. That would raise the 10-year Treasury yield from 4% to 6.6% and 30-year mortgage rates from 6.3% to 8.9%. The trust fund would cease to be a fiscal rule and become, in the words of the CRFB, “more like any other government program.”

Commission for a Responsible Federal Budget
Social Security has paid benefits from payroll taxes since the 1930s. By law, it can only pay what its trust fund contains, which is why benefits automatically decrease when the fund is depleted. Johnson’s plan would remove that limit and send the bill to the Treasury, which is already borrowing to cover a deficit.
Johnson’s case
Johnson claims Americans have been misled about how Social Security is funded. A Senate Budget Committee report he released the same day, titled “Social Security: The Reality…A Legal Ponzi Scheme,” projects a deficit of about $511 billion by 2032.
“Your money was spent to pay current beneficiaries or fund other government programs,” Johnson said, according to the National News Desk, and future benefits will be paid with money from “your sons and daughters who were working at that time,” plus loans.
MacGuineas agreed with part of his argument. Johnson says Congress should fix the deficit as a whole instead of cutting Social Security, and she called that a “reasonable position.” But she said a law “that fails to fix Social Security while increasing the debt” was not the way to get there, and suggested lawmakers do it, perhaps through a bipartisan commission.
Johnson has also recently taken aim at his own camp. After the Republican defeats in the midterms, he declared in a Fox News In his November 7 interview, there was corruption “within the government — I’m sad to say, within the Trump administration,” highlighting claims by Calley Means, a former White House health adviser, that top aides were catering to special interests.
“Our supporters expected us to drain the swamp, but it seems the swamp won,” he said. He later said he was talking about “deep state actors in every administration,” and he pushed to delay the Senate Republican leadership elections for what he called “soul searching discussions.”
Scare the seniors
Johnson has used the bill’s title before. In July 2011, he and 12 other new Republican senators sent a letter to then-President Barack Obama accusing him of trying to “scare old people” by warning that Social Security checks could be at risk if Congress did not raise the debt ceiling.
The debt ceiling returns. TD Securities expects the current $41.1 trillion limit to become binding in January, with the government running out of room to maneuver by around September 2027. That’s five years before the trust fund runs out, and Johnson’s bill would put Social Security on the same borrowed money.
Generative AI was used for research assistance and/or transcription of this article. The journalist independently reported and verified the factual claims in this article, and a human editor reviewed it before publication.
Gn headline