
San Diego abandons Flock cameras and smart streetlights
At Monday’s city council meeting, police officials said there has been a 20 percent drop in vehicle thefts since 2023, with 689 stolen vehicles recovered using Flock cameras.
Rejected
The vote was a remarkable turnaround from just three years ago, when the mayor and other city leaders urged the City Council to approve the program.
The city’s total rejection of these devices included Ubicquia’s so-called “smart streetlights” that worked in concert with Flock’s AI-driven automatic license plate reader (ALPR) software. This shutdown of smart streetlights marks the second time in less than a decade that San Diego has experimented with and ultimately rejected the technology.
At one point, San Diego purchased thousands of smart street lighting systems from another vendor, GE Current, but a previous city administration shut them down in 2020. After that, Ubicquia acquired the smart city platform and proposed a new installation of 500 cameras in 2023 in partnership with Flock – and with police support – which was installed in 2023.
At the time, a local watchdog agency, the City of San Diego Privacy Advisory Council, asked the City Council to reject the project. One of the board members, Pegah Parsi, wrote on LinkedIn that she now feels “vindicated.”
“A reminder to every city, agency, and institution: If you create an expert advisory board, listen to them! she wrote. “Actually, listen to them seriously. It’s cheaper than learning the hard way. Do better.”
That sentiment is echoed by Secure Justice, an Oakland-based advocacy group that studies and monitors Flock issues across the country.
“We have documented at least 513 Flock contracts that have ended in red and blue states, in cities large and small,” Brian Hofer, the group’s executive director, emailed Ars. “It’s pretty clear that Americans do not accept their government monitoring them in our daily lives.”
Gn usa