
Stand out in a Slop AI job market by getting a little weird
Amanda McDormand’s cover letter opened with a bold argument.
“This isn’t a job application, it’s an idea, and I’m going straight to it. I’m a business fixer. If you watched Scandalthinks Olivia Pope. If you are more of the type Ray Donovan no one, that works too. And if you like music, I like to think of myself as the Taylor Swift of business.”
It’s one of several Hail Mary strategies McDormand, 43, tried when he entered an unfamiliar landscape after being laid off from Comcast in December. In 2019, the New Hampshire-based executive turned down offers while exploring new job opportunities. This time, his LinkedIn feed was flooded with messages about job seekers who had sent hundreds of unanswered applications over several years of searching. Still, she wasn’t prepared for her inbox to be flooded with automatic rejections.
With a few months of severance, McDormand decided she had time to experiment – and not much to lose.
She tried the direct route with an “I’m not an AI” element in her cover letter. In another, she weaved golf references for a hiring manager who loved the sport. Her experiences did indeed lead to more call-backs, but her first big win — which resulted in a partial role before her current full-time job — was a cover letter laced with Taylor Swift lyrics. She described “identifying the empty space” within an organization, told the employer that he had “already seen this movie and it was time to change the ending,” and concluded by saying, “This could be our time, just say ‘yes.’
As AI invades the job market, candidates are taking drastic measures to show hiring managers that they’re human – and nothing is off the table. Beyond cover letter conundrums, recruiters say they’ve seen a resurgence of resume interest sections with odd details and more candid personal statements. Some include fun infographics. Others may deliberately include punctuation or spelling errors to indicate that they wrote it themselves.
Carly Martinetti, co-founder of AI PR and visibility firm Notably, said one job seeker mentioned in her LinkedIn contact that she had “been an inside girl my whole career.” It’s “absolutely not something the AI would say,” Martinetti said, adding that she found the message matter-of-fact.
Among the applications that recruiters and candidates shared with me: “buffalo chicken wraps”, the legal drama “Suits”, “vampire and Robert Pattinson films”, “the clown”, “mermaids”, “lucid dreams”, “love of fries”, “superheroes” and “movie-themed dinner party planner”.
Candidates ask themselves, “How can I effectively communicate to people that I am not a machine?”Marc Cenedella, founder and CEO of Ladders
This effort comes at a time when more than 84% of job seekers are using AI to write or edit their resumes, according to data from a recent Ladders survey. The report also reveals that 76% of 237 job seekers surveyed have taken at least one deliberate step to be less like AI.
Before AI, Ladders founder and CEO Marc Cenedella says he “rarely saw people add personal anecdotes to their resumes. It was almost a misstep.”
These days, Cenedella says, candidates ask themselves, “How can I effectively signal to people that I’m not a machine?”
Job seekers have long found a way to tailor their resume by including marathon training, self-employment, or volunteer work in a section labeled “hobbies,” “skills,” or “extracurricular activities.” Likewise, cover letters gave candidates space to elaborate on their accomplishments, explain a career change, or reveal a little more about themselves.
In a crowded job market, these extra details appear in stranger places – and sometimes take a less conventional and creaky form. Candidates who spent months sending out resumes without getting a response said they finally adopted a “shithole” mentality. Some wrote sad cover letters and posted them on social media to share their frustration.
A Reddit user shared a cover letter in a post titled “The cover letter I finally had the courage to send because I have nothing to lose,” which began with the story of their various unanswered applications to the company. If a niche faith catches a hiring manager’s eye, some candidates think it might be worth a little embarrassment.
This decision is also a response to the considerable volume of applications that recruiters now have to sort through. A 2026 Greenhouse analysis found that companies receive an average of 194 applications per hire. AI has made the process of screening hundreds of resumes even more monotonous. Many recruiters are tired of reading perfectly tailored resumes that pull language exactly from the job description and AI-polished 300-word notes that all seem vaguely similar.
“When you look at resumes for an hour, you start to get really picky,” said Kristin Raiford, an executive recruiter who previously led executive search for Amazon ads and finance. “You ask yourself, what’s different between this person and the last person? Why do I choose them and not them?”
The same Greenhouse report indicates that 3.2% of applications make it to a first interview. These days, treating college football as a hobby may not be enough to set you apart from the masses. However, claiming to know the first 100 digits of pi can be enough to give a hiring manager pause. Technology and marketing recruiter Kelli Hrivnak still remembers the resume submitted years ago by a candidate who claimed exactly that. The person wasn’t hired, and it didn’t change their view of their qualifications – but it stuck with them.
McDormand recently received 220 applications for a position she posted a few days earlier. The candidates who catch their attention are the ones who give the recruiter something to remember, weird or not.
“After seeing it a dozen times, you’re like, ‘I don’t know who this person is. This person isn’t giving me anything,'” McDormand said, adding that she appreciates the unconventional approach.
Sharing a quirky interest or hobby offers a two-for-one advantage to some candidates. This can take a hiring manager out of resume fatigue and also give the candidate an easy transition to talking about their skills in an interview.
Kelsey Anderson, a graduate student currently applying for a job, lists “Julia Child” in the interest section of her resume. This can lead to a simple conversation about cooking or help him move on to a deeper topic. For example, she might discuss American food dynamics, Child’s love of travel, her late-career pivot, or her feminist advocacy.
For others, hobbies reflect their skills. Paige Maly, who works in marketing, said she received more callbacks than ever after adding a visual ladder of five of her wildest adventures to her resume.
Paige Maly said she received more callbacks than ever after adding a visual ladder of adventures to her resume. Paige Maly
She said this section has become a topic of conversation in every interview. For Maly, it was more than a twist. It was proof of the qualities she believes marketers look for: independence, decisiveness and a willingness to take risks.
“I’m OK with moving,” Maly said.
All of these tactics are ultimately a gamble, even if they pay off. Although a bold move may lead to a job offer, it could also discourage the recruiter. Some hiring managers may appreciate this extra touch, but others prefer to keep resumes strictly professional.
Erica Keswin, a former executive recruiter and best-selling author of workplace strategy and people leadership, said including outlandish details could “really backfire on the wrong people.” Creative industries might be more receptive to this approach, but old-fashioned law firms or consulting giants might not be as keen on eccentric confessions. Keswin said including a unique hobby can be a smart move to humanize your application, but she wouldn’t recommend diving into a particularly weird confession just because it worked for someone else.
“I wouldn’t always say ‘plug and play,’” Keswin said. “Because if it doesn’t sound like you and someone asks you about it, it will have the opposite effect.”
For McDormand, a self-described “Swiftie for Life,” it felt genuine, although she said she researched companies before sending out applications to decide whether to take the traditional or creative route.. McDormand said incorporating song lyrics into her application gave her an opportunity in an interview to spend 10 minutes discussing Swift’s marketing playbook and how she used similar tactics to stand out. She said the ability to connect pop culture to meaningful strategy was both effective and memorable.
Those conversations are what had the biggest impact on getting a job, she said.
“It’s a technique to get in the door,” McDormand says, “But once you get in the door, you have to have the wherewithal to be able to back up the conversation.”
Business Insider’s Discourse articles deliver perspectives on today’s most pressing issues, informed by analysis, reporting, and expertise.
Gn bussni