
Tenant of collapsed Brooklyn building warned landlord about cracks, lawsuit says
A Brooklyn musician left homeless when his apartment building collapsed onto an adjacent construction site is suing his landlord and several construction companies, saying he warned them about cracks near the building’s Flatbush Avenue entrance.
In a complaint filed Monday evening in Brooklyn Supreme Court, tenant Dengane Omari Jack said he “photographed these cracks and reported the condition to the owner or management responsible for the building” in October, a few weeks before the disaster killed eight people, including two children, and injured several others.
Jack claims the owner, Olufemi Falade, ignored the complaint, responding “that the condition was not the owner’s fault or could not be repaired” and that he “failed to arrange for an adequate and timely structural investigation, obtain necessary protection or repairs, or take appropriate action in response to the reported condition and ongoing adjacent excavations.”
Falade owns the property through a limited liability company called Isolag Realty Corp. The city’s Department of Housing Preservation and Development documented 98 violations at the four-unit building, including unsafe electrical wiring and inadequate water supply from the sprinkler system, before it collapsed.
The lawsuit also names the owners of the adjacent construction site — limited liability companies linked to Robert Fischman and Judy Swimer — and a host of companies and individuals involved in the project, including general contractor Townhouse Builders, subcontractor Elite Concrete, structural engineer Jieming Wang of LMW Engineering and special inspections agency RI Consulting Services Inc.
Falade did not immediately respond to a telephone message seeking comment Tuesday.
The building where Jack lived at 1321 Flatbush Ave. collapsed onto the adjacent construction site around 4 p.m. on November 11, taking with it the facade of another adjacent apartment building. Rescue operations continued the next day as first responders searched the debris for survivors and deceased people.
“Our client obviously extends his condolences to the families of everyone killed and best wishes to everyone injured,” Jack’s attorney, Scott Epstein, said in a telephone interview Tuesday. “The loss of his residence and all of his possessions traumatized him. »
The city Department of Buildings has yet to determine the cause of the deadly collapse and has launched a safety blitz on other projects run by the same companies as the Flatbush project. A Gothamist analysis found that inspectors visited at least 24 sites associated with LMW Engineering and RI Consulting Services and stopped work at five sites.
LMW Engineering, RI Consulting Services, Townhouse Builders, Elite Concrete, Fischman and Swimer did not respond to requests for comment on the collapse.
Fischman and Swimer received approval to build a three-story apartment complex on the land after demolishing a single-story commercial building. They applied for permission to build a nine-story complex with a grocery store on the first floor in September, but the city had not yet approved the plan before the collapse.
The city’s Building Department halted demolition work at the site in March after finding missing safety measures. The ministry then fined the development team $10,000 for carrying out the demolition despite the order.
Building records show the neighboring building was in disrepair before collapsing. A pre-construction report documented the “poor” condition of the side façade facing the construction site, although the engineering firm that prepared it indicated it could not access the building.
Excavation safety plans prepared by LMW Engineer Jieming Wang called for steel support beams, called rakers, at every location along the perimeter of the lot except the collapse site.
Tenants living at 1321 Flatbush Ave. had problems in the building long before the fatal collapse. The building has been through the city’s tax lien sale process for unpaid municipal debt at least five times over the past decade, according to court and property records.
Falade also has a questionable record as an owner.
A judge sent him to jail for 12 days in 2006 for offenses committed in another building.
Gn usa