The $45 Bourbon That’s Not Worth the Hype and 2 Alternatives with More Flavor
Many of us have fallen victim to the idea that good bourbon should cost a pretty penny. If you’re spending around $45 on a bottle, you’re probably assuming you’re getting something with big personality and great taste. But that’s exactly where a bourbon like Basil Hayden can disappoint. While it’s a well-respected name in the whiskey department, its relatively low proof and lighter flavor profile leaves many bourbon drinkers wishing for more.
But you don’t have to take our word for it. We spoke with Chris Walster, whiskey guru at The Cask Connoisseur, to get his take on what’s worth drinking these days. When asked which overpriced bourbons you should leave on the shelves, Basil Hayden was one of his first choices. “It’s approachable and easy to drink,” he says, “but at 80 proof it can seem quite light for the price.”
Basil Hayden Kentucky Straight Bourbon is made by Jim Beam and has a distinctive high-rye mash bill, giving it a spicier profile than other sweeter corn-based bourbons. You can expect notes of vanilla, caramel, black pepper and charred oak, with a brief and fairly clean finish. At 80 proof (40% ABV), it is lighter for bourbon. This isn’t necessarily a bad thing, but it can mean that a bourbon has less intensity and body than its stronger competitors. That’s why Walster advises opting for a different whiskey: “There are bourbons at a similar price that offer much more flavor and character, including Knob Creek and Wild Turkey 101.”
Knob Creek and Wild Turkey 101 are cheaper and tastier
One of the alternatives Chris Walster recommends is Knob Creek bourbon, which is actually another member of Jim Beam’s small batch whiskey collection. Its age statement of 9 years and 100 proof bottling make it a much more substantial whiskey than Basil Hayden, all for a lower price. While Basil Hayden costs around $45, Knob Creek is listed at around $35. Its prolonged aging gives it a fuller mouthfeel and a deeper, woodier character. This higher proof also produces a long, rich, warm finish that doesn’t disappear as quickly as that of basil.
Walster’s other choice? Good old Wild Turkey 101. This popular Kentucky bourbon offers a more potent drinking experience at a significantly lower price than Basil Hayden and Knob Creek. At 101 proof, it’s considerably stronger than Basil Hayden, but the appeal isn’t just in the extra alcohol. Wild Turkey is aged for six to eight years in heavily charred American white oak barrels, giving it that deep honey color and bold flavor. Its higher content makes it particularly useful in bourbon cocktails like the Old Fashioned, where it more than holds its own. At around $20-25, it’s significantly cheaper than Basil Hayden.
Of course, we’re not saying Basil Hayden is a bad bourbon. It is an approachable spirit that is very popular among drinkers who prefer a lighter whiskey. But if you’re willing to spend $45, there are much better opportunities to get more body and complexity for your money. It is always worth remembering Walster’s advice: “Buy the whisky, not the hype.” »
Gn tech