
The ICJ will rule on the Rohingya genocide case against Myanmar: what are the issues? | News on crimes against humanity
The United Nations’ highest court is to rule on whether Myanmar committed genocide against its Rohingya Muslim minority in a case brought by the West African nation of Gambia.
The International Court of Justice (ICJ) in The Hague is due to deliver its verdict on Thursday in what will be its first judgment on the merits of a genocide case in more than a decade.
Recommended Stories
list of 3 itemsend of list
Legal experts said the ruling could have consequences for South Africa’s ongoing lawsuit accusing Israel of genocide in Gaza, which Israel disputes.
The Gambia accuses Myanmar of seeking to destroy the Rohingya people during a 2017 military crackdown that forced hundreds of thousands to flee. Myanmar, for its part, claims to be responding to attacks by Arakan Rohingya Salvation Army (ARSA) fighters on police posts.
Here’s what we know:
What happened to the Rohingya in Myanmar?
Myanmar’s military launched what it called mine clearance operations in Rakhine state in October 2016 and a much larger campaign in August 2017 after attacks on police posts by a Rohingya armed group. Around 10,000 Rohingya were killed and 740,000 forced to flee to Bangladesh, according to UN estimates.
U.N. investigators found that soldiers razed hundreds of villages, carried out massacres and routinely raped and raped Rohingya women, girls and boys. They said the sexual violence indicated genocidal intent.
The military itself announced convictions in only two cases brought after the violence. However, in one, seven soldiers imprisoned for killing 10 Rohingya men and boys in Inn Din village were released after serving less than a year of their 10-year sentence.

In 1982, long before the crackdown, Myanmar excluded the Rohingya from its 135 recognized ethnic groups, labeling them Bengali immigrants, even though many families have lived in Myanmar for generations. Since then, almost all Rohingya have been denied citizenship, making them the largest stateless group in the world.
Since fighting resumed with the army in 2023, the Arakan Army, an ethnic Rakhine armed group, has seized most of the state. The Office of the United Nations High Commissioner for Human Rights said in August that the two forces had committed widespread and systematic abuses against the Rohingya, accusing the Arakan Army of torture, sexual violence and forced recruitment.

The UN said these abuses have driven more than 155,000 Rohingya to come to Bangladesh since the start of 2024, bringing the number of refugees to around 1.2 million.
Nearly all the refugees live in crowded camps in Cox’s Bazar district, where they rely on international aid that has declined sharply in recent years, particularly since U.S. President Donald Trump’s administration cut foreign aid in 2025. Most refugees now receive smaller food rations, and many schools in the camps have closed. The United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees has warned that new arrivals often lack food, clean water and health care.
Why did the Gambia take Myanmar to the ICJ?
The Gambia said it filed the complaint after decades of persecution of the Rohingya that culminated in the 2017 operation, which it said violated the 1948 Genocide Convention.
The Muslim-majority nation of 2.5 million filed the lawsuit in November 2019 on behalf of the 57 members of the Organization of Islamic Cooperation (OIC). The case was led by Abubacarr Tambadou, then Attorney General and Minister of Justice of The Gambia.
In January 2020, the court ordered Myanmar to take emergency measures to prevent acts of genocide.
Myanmar initially argued that Gambia, which was not directly involved in the conflict, could not file a complaint. But in 2022, judges ruled that it was possible because both countries are parties to the convention, under which all signatories are required to prevent and punish genocide.
Hearings on the merits of the case followed in January this year, with seven states – including Canada, France and the United Kingdom – supporting Gambia.

What exactly should the ICJ decide?
Judges must decide whether Myanmar as a state committed genocide against the Rohingya, violating the 1948 Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide.
The ICJ makes judgments on state actions. It does not rule on the criminal culpability of individual soldiers or commanders.
Under the convention, “genocide” refers to acts such as murder and causing serious harm, committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnic, racial or religious group.
It is not enough to prove that a state has committed atrocities. The court must also find that they were committed with the specific intent to destroy a group. Such intention may be demonstrated by direct statements or orders or inferred from a pattern of behavior.
The Gambia has argued that genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion of Myanmar’s conduct.
Myanmar, meanwhile, said it was conducting a legitimate counterterrorism operation against Rohingya fighters, and was not targeting the Rohingya people as a whole.
What would a finding of genocide mean for the Rohingya?
A finding of genocide would formally recognize the harm suffered by the Rohingya, but may have no short-term effect for more than a million victims of violence and displacement, said Michael Becker, professor of international law at Trinity College Dublin and former ICJ jurist.
The Gambia wants the court to order Myanmar to ensure that displaced Rohingya can safely return to their land, compensate them and replace or rebuild destroyed homes and property.
Becker told Al Jazeera that the court could impose these requirements only in part or in general terms, leaving Myanmar to decide how to comply.
Such an outcome “would surely be disappointing” to those who doubt the government will respond to these requests in good faith, he said.

“Even if the ICJ were to order large-scale relief measures, the political conditions on the ground in Myanmar make it impossible to obtain such relief in the near future,” Becker said.
He said a finding should instead be used to put diplomatic pressure on Myanmar.
William Schabas, professor of international law at Middlesex University in the United Kingdom, said The Gambia’s requested measures for the Rohingya were “robust”, although they did not require citizenship, which would end their statelessness.
“Assuming that Myanmar implements the findings, this will indeed have significant positive effects on the safety, dignity and livelihoods of the Rohingya in Myanmar,” Schabas told Al Jazeera.

What could be the consequences of this decision for future genocide cases?
Myanmar’s decision will be the first final judgment on five genocide cases pending before the ICJ.
Becker said the outcome could clarify the court’s long-standing test of “the only reasonable inference.” Under this law, judges infer genocidal intent from a pattern of behavior only if no other reasonable explanation is suitable.
He said the court’s two rulings on the Balkan wars left it unclear whether genocide could be considered to occur alongside armed conflict, which he said was “an unduly restrictive standard.”
Thursday’s ruling may instead view armed conflict as an alternative explanation for party conduct, rather than an automatic bar to establishing genocidal intent, he said.
According to Schabas, the decision “will have very dramatic effects” on the outcome of other pending cases, including the one against Israel.
“In my opinion, South Africa’s case against Israel is much stronger than Gambia’s case against Myanmar. If Gambia wins against Myanmar, we can be sure that South Africa will prevail over Israel,” he said.
Gn world