
UnitedHealth, other insurance stocks send Dow lower after CMS proposes new anti-fraud rule
Healthcare stocks fell again on Wednesday after the Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services (CMS) proposed a new rule that would strengthen oversight of Medicare, Medicaid, the Children’s Health Insurance Program (CHIP) and the health insurance market.
Slumping shares of managed care providers weighed on the Dow Jones Industrial Average (^DJI), sending the blue-chip index to a session low. UnitedHealth Group (UNH) stock, one of the largest constituents of the Dow with a weighting of 4.32%, fell about 8%. Humana (HUM) fell 8%. Cigna (CI) shares fell more than 2%. CVS Health (CVS), which is spinning off its retail and insurance businesses, fell 3%.
Learn more: Out-of-pocket Medicare spending increases in 2027
The rule, called Comprehensive Regulations for Uncovering Suspicious Health Care, or CRUSH, would increase audits of insurers and allow CMS to recover improper payments. It would also require providers to report changes to registration information within 30 days, among other requirements.
In the statement shared Monday, officials highlighted bad actors billing Medicare for nonexistent wheelchairs, enrolling healthy seniors in Medicare-funded hospice care, and enrolling people in Marketplace plans without their consent as examples of the types of fraud this rule aims to crack down on.
CMS said this rule could save taxpayers nearly $90 billion over the next 10 years. The proposal is open for public comment until January 19, 2027.
However, Oppenheimer analysts said they expect the proposal to face legal scrutiny similar to a framework that a federal court struck down in 2025. Additionally, the team noted that the $90 billion in savings likely reflects CMS reimbursements rather than broad savings on health programs.
“We believe CMS will be subject to the same legal challenges as in 2025,” the analysts write. “The much higher collection estimate reflects a broader audit, with collections focused on 2028-2030. This is a proposed rule, so CMS could choose to make adjustments in the final rule. Even if the rule were implemented as is and upheld by the courts, we believe plans would incorporate the prospective cost into bids rather than absorbing an unchanged recurring revenue burden.”
354.45 -35.23 (-9.04%)
At 1:34:32 p.m. EST. Open market.
UNH ^DJI
Gn bussni