
Witness recounts botched Texas execution: ‘Such horror, such terror and such pain’ | Death penalty
“Take me, father!”
It was one of many screams made by Reinaldo Dennes Thursday evening as he was strapped to a gurney in a Texas death chamber as prison officials struggled, for more than an hour, to carry out his execution.
The Rev. Jeff Hood, Dennes’ spiritual advisor, stood by his side, his hand on the condemned man’s shoulder throughout the lethal injection, a procedure that witnesses said went horribly wrong.
“The energy coming out of him was so much horror and terror and pain, it was overwhelming,” Hood said Friday morning.
Dennes’ was the 15th execution Hood witnessed. A staunch advocate of capital punishment, the reverend regularly serves as a spiritual leader to death row inmates across the United States, offering counsel to prisoners during their final months – and sometimes guarding them in their final minutes. Thirteen of these executions were lethal injections.
Dennes’ procedure, Hood said, was the worst lethal injection he had witnessed — by far.
Before Thursday, Dennes, 70, had spent three decades on death row, sentenced to death for the 1996 murder of Janos Szucs, a diamond merchant. In the weeks before his planned killing, Dennes was at peace, Hood said.
“He was borderline euphoric about dying – he was so excited about getting out of prison and meeting God,” Hood said. “In the holding cell, he said, ‘Don’t be sad. It’s great. I’m going home.'”
After the nearby church bells tolled at 6 p.m., authorities escorted the witnesses into the Huntsville Unit, a Texas prison opened in 1849. In typical Texas executions, witnesses were brought into the death chamber shortly thereafter, after the prisoner was strapped in and an intravenous line established. But on Thursday, they had to wait. And wait.
Hood said he knew something was wrong. Authorities, he surmised, were probably having difficulty establishing the IV line to administer pentobarbital, a deadly sedative. Executioners across the country have experienced similar struggles, including the botched and botched execution of Christa Pike in Tennessee in September.
After about 30 minutes, the witnesses were brought into the execution room. Hood saw that IV lines had been placed in Dennes’ neck and foot.
Hood put his hand on Dennes’ shoulder, he recalled. He told Dennes how much he loved him and thanked him for their friendship. In his closing remarks, Dennes said he was “extremely blessed,” according to the Associated Press story, and that he hoped his family members “learn to know this great gift and this great grace of God the Father.”
The reverend recalled that Dennes signaled he was ready to continue, shouting, “Come on, keeper!”
The pentobarbital started flowing at 6:52 p.m., according to a prison spokesperson.
Authorities said the drug should quickly render people unconscious. Hood has already witnessed three lethal injections in Texas and said those procedures went “without a hitch.”
It was different.
Dennes’ body began to heave under Hood’s hand, he said.
“He’s still moving, he’s still moving, he’s pulling on the leather straps and I can feel his shoulder pushing into my palm,” Hood said. Dennes, he said, felt like a “rebellious bronco.”
Dennes screamed, “My leg, my leg! … (It’s) killing me,” shouting that he felt like he was on fire, according to Hood.
For several minutes, Dennes’ screams continued, screaming, “Fuck! Fuck!” and “Damn!”, Hood said. The fact that he was able to utter any words after a minute was extremely distressing, Hood said, and it soon became clear that he was begging for it to end.
“I don’t think it’s normal,” Dennes said, according to Hood. “Take me, father! Don’t let me suffer like this.”
Hood said his hand remained on Dennes’ shoulder even though Dennes repeatedly made it clear that he knew the execution was not proceeding according to procedure.
Dennes eventually made several loud moans, followed by the kind of snoring that typically occurs at the start of a lethal injection, Hood said. Dennes’ breathing became calmer, then finally stopped.
The execution ended at 7:07 p.m., 63 minutes after Dennes was first tied up, according to the AP. A minute later, a doctor officially pronounced him dead.
“He was tortured to death. It reminded me of the phenomenon of simulated drowning – constantly pushing someone to their limits,” Hood said. “They were going to do whatever it took to carry out this execution.”
Amanda Hernandez, a spokeswoman for the Texas Department of Criminal Justice, told reporters the execution followed state procedures, saying staff placed IVs in Dennes’ foot and neck after having difficulty finding suitable veins.
Hernandez, the AP reported, further suggested that Dennes may have faked his pain, noting that he was complaining about his leg, which was not a direct injection site.
“To say that Reinaldo was doing theater is absolutely disturbing and disgusting,” Hood said. “Reinaldo was completely at peace when I walked into that room. He was a very contemplative guy who was remorseful for what he had done and ready to leave this life. There’s no reason why he should have immediately turned to these theaters.” Hood also scoffed at the idea that Dennes didn’t feel pain in his leg because the injection site was in his foot: “Has Amanda Hernandez ever been injected with pentobarbital? How does she know?”
“After 30 seconds, he shouldn’t have been able to respond at all,” Hood added.
Hood said Hernandez and Bobby Lumpkin, the department’s executive director, should resign, following in the footsteps of the Tennessee prison chief who resigned after Pike’s botched execution.
“We want to be able to trust what the government says, but these statements (that this is not a botched execution) are simply not credible,” Hood said. “For them, the execution was successful because he died.”
Hernandez said in an email that the department “denies any assertion that the execution was ‘botched.’
“The overall process took about an hour, which is not atypical,” she wrote, saying the agency “took its time to ensure the IVs were inserted into viable veins.” She said Dennes complained of pain before the drugs were administered.
Reports of Dennes’ botched execution have sparked renewed calls for a moratorium on lethal injections.
Supporters of the death penalty, Hood said, must confront the reality of what happens in execution chambers.
“Having your hands on someone and not being able to do anything but stay, that’s a horror I feel,” he said. “But it should be something that everyone should feel. If the state is going to kill people, then everyone should have to deal with that closeness. How many people would get the death penalty if they had to engage in those moments where these guys look at you and say, ‘Help me,’ and there’s absolutely nothing you can do?”
Gn headline