
Democrats turn to expensive ICE prison purchases
Zoom: A facility purchased by ICE for $495 million in 2026 has been offered for sale (but not sold) to the state of Minnesota for $75 million in 2025, according to KARE 11.
- As of mid-November, ICE had paid between $230 million and $739 million each for six detention centers from CoreCivic and The Geo Group, two private prison companies that have won major government contracts and record revenues since Trump returned to office.
- The facilities were sold for well above their publicly traded property tax assessment, according to state and local records, and the companies will continue to be paid to operate the facilities.
- Sen. Maggie Hassan (D-N.H.) — set to chair the Senate committee overseeing DHS — has opened an investigation into the Minnesota purchase. Rep. Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.) — set to chair the House Homeland Security Committee — has vowed to investigate the contracts and alleged self-dealing.
Between the lines: “There appears to be a discrepancy between the value of the property … and what DHS is paying,” said Art Arthur, a former Republican Judiciary Committee oversight attorney and oversight committee member.
- “But that in itself is not necessarily indicative of waste, fraud or abuse.”
- “The first thing I would do is call ICE and ask them, you know, what was going on, why this was necessary, and ask them to respond,” said Arthur, now a researcher at the Center for Immigration Studies.
- A Government Accountability Office report released in September said ICE purchases had “the potential to result in waste” and that the agency had not “evaluated the long-term affordability of owning these facilities.”
- Another November report was requested by several Democrats, including Thompson.
The other side: DHS did not respond to questions about these purchases.
- In an emailed statement, a spokesperson said, “The purchase price was determined using the standard federal appraisal process. The independent appraisers applied a replacement cost method, the current cost of equivalent secure space, adjusted for depreciation, terrain and condition, including security and fire improvements required for ICE operations. »
- The release also said CoreCivic’s offer to Minnesota for the Prairie Correctional Facility “was a preliminary, non-binding indication offered in prior discussions.”
- The Government Services Administration, which manages federal agency buildings, said it was not involved in the purchases. The Geo Group did not respond to a request for comment.
- CoreCivic’s public affairs office said its contracts “are awarded through long-established federal processes and our real estate transactions follow the appraisal standards that govern federal property purchases.”
Zoom out: This spending spree follows an earlier attempt by former DHS Secretary Kristi Noem to own and convert warehouses into detention spaces to the tune of $38 billion.
- DHS withdrew from that project, spending only a fraction of that amount, and is now selling most of the warehouses purchased under Noem.
- The ICE detainee population has roughly doubled from the end of former President Biden’s term.
What they say: “These prices only make sense for an agency that has more money than it knows what to do with,” said Claire Trickler-McNulty, who worked at DHS and ICE during the Obama, Biden and Trump administrations and oversaw ICE detention standards.
- “Taxpayers deserve public accountability for what the agency makes by owning these buildings, what they will cost to operate and maintain them over time, and how that fits into a long-term plan,” she said.
- But in this political climate, Arthur said, “it might be appropriate and necessary for DHS to pay a premium for these properties because it needs space in these areas.”
The essentials: “With all due respect to my Republican majority and my donors, they just let them do what they wanted,” said Rep. Henry Cuellar (D-Texas), who will lead the House Appropriations subcommittee overseeing DHS.
- Cuellar expects it will be possible to recoup some of the unspent portion of the $113 billion allocated to ICE – but not obligated – thanks to Trump’s “One Big, Beautiful Bill.”
Gn world