October 10, 2026Updated October 11, 2026, 12:57 a.m. ET
Progressive Field was a goddamn madhouse Saturday night, with some 37,000 Cleveland Guardians fans feeling the urgency that only a winner-take-all fifth game can produce.
On the field, however, four matches of chaos gave way to calm. Four matches of uncertainty resulted in the Guardians returning to normal, as they know it.
Gavin Williams, untouchable.
José Ramírez, unstoppable.
A bullpen beaten by the Chicago White Sox in this American League Division Series once again on the verge. And the Guardians, back in the AL Championship Series for the second time in three seasons.
Their surprise 2-0 blowout of the White Sox ended five arrhythmic and sometimes ugly games between the central rivals and bought them a ticket to Tampa Bay, where they will face the heavily favored Rays in the ALCS starting Monday in St. Petersburg.
Heavily favored, as these Guardians fell into a 2-0 ALDS hole, crawled back to set things right with an ugly Game 4 win in which both teams combined to walk 15 batters, then moved forward using every ounce of their pitching staff to outlast Chicago.
In Game 5, that meant burning Williams, their ace who was tied for the AL lead in strikeouts.
It was worth it.
Williams produced one of the most dominant performances in Cleveland playoff history, striking out 12 to tie Charles Nagy for the most punchouts in a playoff game. Combined with his 11 strikeouts in five innings of Game 2 (the Guardians bullpen blew that one) and another strikeout in his only inning to end Game 4 (yes, it’s been that kind of series), Williams struck out 24 in 11 ⅔ innings.
“It was big boy stuff today,” Cleveland manager Stephen Vogt said of Williams. “It was, ‘I’ve got you guys. I’m going to be on my A-game and I’m going to give you as many shots as I can.'”
That’s the kind of dominance needed in this modern game that’s all about keeping the ball out of play at all costs, even if your starter can only go five or six innings. It worked in Game 5: Chicago put only eight balls in play, produced no extra base hits, and Cleveland’s batters broke a playoff record with 21 at-bats as a team.
The White Sox also almost played this run prevention game to perfection in Game 5. But they had to deal with Ramírez.
One of the greatest players in Cleveland baseball history made the difference in this game. The White Sox released their only normal, well-adjusted starting pitcher in Sean Burke, who this time wouldn’t need an opener.
Instead, he largely carved up the Guardians for five innings, walking none, striking out four and delivering a well-executed 2-2 knuckle curve to Ramírez in the bottom of the fourth.
But he’s one of the biggest hitters we’ve ever seen. And Ramírez came down and picked up the pitch, which was barely an inch above the ground, and bludgeoned it. Just high enough, just far enough, just over the right field fence at Progressive, a hit artist in his own studio.
Suddenly, what moments earlier was a no-hitter double became a 2-0 lead for the Guardians. Ramírez responded to the crowd with a noise coming from the dugout that was half a reminder, half an exhortation. The roar was so loud that it drowned out the “Country Roads” salute to which Chase DeLauter, the next batter, approached.
It was appropriate. Ramírez was a shell of himself this season, a victim of the hamate injury that, for some reason, was particularly rampant this year. Yet once the Guardians won the division title, Ramírez was able to rest and take advantage of the first-round bye.
He already looks like a different guy.
Ramírez also hit a two-run home run in Game 4, this one off flamethrower Jordan Hicks. This ball? He was almost in his eyes, in the strike zone, coming in at 99.9 mph.
Two plays, two swings, two completely different pitches and the same result that turns the series.
The Guardians may not have the dynamic and dangerous up-and-down lineup that the Rays will bring to the ALCS. But they will have Ramírez, who will aim for a return to the World Series a decade after his Cleveland team fell short in 2016.
“We can’t wait to play Monday,” Vogt says, “and I can’t wait to continue to see Jose Ramírez do what he does.”
This might not be enough. The Guardians’ bullpen is also pretty well-cooked, with standout closer Cade Smith forced to go multiple innings in Games 4 and 5, recording his first career five-out save in the clincher. He started all five games in the ALDS and his returns could decline further in the ALCS.
But in this decisive fifth game that affirmed the Guardians as a playoff problem, following Ramírez’s lead was certainly enough.
Get Guardians vs Rays ALCS tickets!
Gn sports
