
I’m the “sister” in the “SNL” care sketch. Here’s What Happened When I Texted It To My Brothers
The first time Mary McFarland saw the “Sister” sketch aired on “Saturday Night Live” on Nov. 14, she laughed. She sent it to her siblings impulsively, thinking it was funny.
“Then no one answered. I’m like, ‘What did I do?'” she told TODAY.com.
But the more McFarland watched the sketch, the less funny it became. It brought back the story that happened 20 years before, when her mother moved in with her while McFarland herself was navigating stage 3 cancer.
Watching the skit and thinking about the turmoil between her and her siblings at the end of her mother’s life, she wondered, “Maybe someone should have taken care of me.” »
The sketch landed on “Saturday Night Live” on Nov. 14 with a stirring thud. The main thing? An advertisement for a product that will intervene and solve all care problems: a sister. The sketch highlights the burden of caretaking that so often, but not always, falls on women. One of the three writers, Streeter Seidell, dedicated the sketch to his sister Heidi.
“Sister is a live-in elder care provider, 24/7, completely free, and so is your sister,” host John Mulaney said in the spoof ad. “Now I don’t have to worry about Dad getting the care and attention he needs because my sister will and I can get on with my life.” »
Since its debut, “Sister” has caused a seismic response, both publicly and in family group chats. One Threads user said the video was causing chaos.
“I started an entire family argument today over this video by sending it to my uncle,” the message read.
The painful reality
For many, “Sister” exposes or affirms pre-existing (and sometimes painful) dynamics between siblings. Psychologist Adriana DeAmicis said in an email to TODAY.com that “every single one” of her clients has brought up the sketch in her sessions since its release.
“Humor gave women permission to laugh at something that is often deeply frustrating: having to take responsibility for everyone’s needs while watching their brothers receive praise for doing much less,” DeAmicis said.
“However, many women discussed this week how quickly they went from laughing to the real pain of a deep, rarely acknowledged wound,” DeAmicis added.
In group discussions between siblings, what is supposed to be fun sharing sparks real conversations and an escalation of tensions over who is responsible for the caregiving burden. Christine Pruden, who spent six years caring for her parents, sent the sketch to her brother.
“Ha!” said his response. “Happy Sunday.”
Pruden, who had been “blown away” by the sketch, said its reaction seemed minimal compared to his own.
“It says everything that a lot of us women feel and have never really been allowed to express, because if you do, you’re a troublemaker or a drama queen,” Pruden says of the sketch.
Pruden responded, “I think there will be a lot of families talking about this skit over Thanksgiving dinner. It hits way too close to home for some of us daughters and older sisters.”

“He had no response to that,” she said.
Kimberly Wiener, who left her job four years ago to care for her disabled elderly mother, sent the video to a group chat that included her seven siblings. She received no response other than a few laughing emojis and a private message from a sister-in-law who asked if “the boys” would feel guilty about the skit.
“My response was, ‘I don’t care, I’m at the ‘see you at the funeral’ stage,” Wiener wrote in an email to TODAY.com, referencing a line from the sketch.
Stacie Kowalski, who took a year off while her father was dying, felt a pang of worry after sending it to her brother.
It says everything that many of us women feel and have never really been allowed to express, because if you do, you’re a troublemaker or a drama queen.”
Christine Pruden on the “Sister” sketch from “SNL”
“I kind of thought, ‘Oh, I hope he doesn’t get angry.’ Then I thought how ridiculous that thought was – putting someone else’s feelings ahead of my own again,” she said in an email to TODAY.com.
Kowalski’s brother did not respond, which she said “is an answer.”
Heather Lister said her brother reacted with laughter to the video. She hopes it provided “an eye-opening perspective” for other brothers.
“What’s so funny to me is that older generations also assume that us girls are going to do it,” she said in an email.
Spark conversation – and hopefully change
For those actively caring for their parents, “Sister” inspires change. Kathryn Hinchey Wise said in a statement to TODAY.com that “her sister” “gave her the courage to say what I had been carrying for months.”
She texted “Sister” during a group chat with her brothers, asking, “Did you watch everything?” » When she received no response, she wrote again, saying she wanted her brothers’ help in moving their father to an assisted living facility floor in her building.
“That message sparked a bitter and prolonged struggle,” she said, which ended with her stepping down as her father’s primary caretaker.
“It wasn’t the outcome I wanted, but it was the outcome I needed,” she said.

Rebecca Cynamon-Murphy, a 49-year-old from suburban Chicago, found the courage to text her brothers inviting them to a meeting about what needs to change in the future. She shared the text exchange on Threads.
“The text was an impulsive and inspired action after watching the skit a second time,” Cynamon-Murphy said in a statement to TODAY.com. “My 2 sisters-in-law immediately joined the group chat to hold them accountable and they are rock stars.”
A meeting, Cynamon-Murphy said, has been set.
Tanya Eby, meanwhile, received a text from her brother the day after he sent the “Sister” skit, specifically to talk about caring for their mother, who had Alzheimer’s disease. Together, Eby said, they “came up with a plan” that lightened his load and increased hers.
“What the sketch did for me was affirm that I wasn’t imagining these roles taking on. I wasn’t hysterical. It really wasn’t fair,” she told TODAY.com. “It allowed me to be very firm in my boundaries. Instead of saying, ‘Oh, I know you’re going through a lot. Don’t worry, I’ll take care of it.’ It allowed me to say, “I hear you. It’s difficult. I still need help with this.’
Eby, who was developing resentment toward her brother, says she hopes the conversation sparked by the skit can improve their relationship in the future.
Meanwhile, for those navigating sibling estrangement, “Sister” is a reminder of the brothers and sisters who are no longer here.
Lia Prusha, a therapist, texted it to her two estranged half-brothers, in part because of her experience with their late parents. Prusha says she didn’t get a response.
“I think sending it is an act of defiance. You can’t make me invisible. I’m a valid person and I exist,” she says.
The caregiver crisis
It should be noted that not all “sisters” are actually sisters. Scott Lerman told TODAY.com in an email that his father turned to him after watching the skit and said, “Oh my God, you’re the sister.”
“They know exactly who I am in our family,” he said.
Eliza Salerno, president and COO of Medical Guardian, a company that helps seniors live safely and independently at home, is not surprised by the earthquake caused by this sketch.
“It is inevitable that the caregiver crisis and what is happening with them (will) become a broader topic of conversation because of the number of people in the country who have to take on this role,” she said.
According to an AARP survey, 63 million Americans would be caregivers in 2025, an increase of 50% since 2015.
Salerno says the crisis is due to the “silver tsunami” — the rapid aging of the U.S. population — health problems and the changing structure of the family unit, driven by bipartisan working households.
“There’s not enough time in the day to work, take care of the kids, live your life and deal with this really new thing that’s happening,” she says.
This leads young women to take into account the reality of the “Sister” sketch in their future projects.
At 31, Olivia Landon has already done her share of caregiving, sitting by her grandmother and great-aunt’s deathbed and putting her life on hold for her mother’s recovery from spinal surgery for two weeks, even though her father was home.
She told TODAY.com in a statement that she texted “Sister” to her family, who “ignored it.” Landon now deliberately lives in New Orleans, too far away for her to continue caring for him.
“Leaving is the only way out,” Landon said.
McFarland, meanwhile, spoke to her own daughter following “Sister” about their future. McFarland moved to Oklahoma to be closer to her daughter and grandchildren and says she now has a “lovely” family dynamic.
“She says, ‘Mom, of course, I’m here for you, and I want to be there for you,'” McFarland says.
Gn entert