
‘Madden’ Review: Nicolas Cage in an Eccentric Sports Biopic Stunt
You could say that each film writes its own rules. But you can Really That’s what we can say about a film in which Nicolas Cage, buried under a big suit that makes him look like Jiminy Glick as John Candy, plays John Madden, the famous coach of the Oakland Raiders at the height of their evil machine of the 70s, who became one of the most unhinged – and influential – television sports commentators of his era.
In David O. Russell’s “Madden,” Cage, wearing a suit that the movie never pretends to forget is a suit (it’s just too synthetic), gives a performance that is two parts imitation, one part Nicolas Cage kabuki. The concept of the film is that Madden, with his outsized physique and even bigger personality, was such a windy man, oblivious to himself, spewing obscenities and shooting from his mouth. character that wrapping Cage in this prosthetic supergeek disguise and letting him tap into the grandiose depths of his inner cage will somehow be a path to…authenticity.
It does and it doesn’t. “Madden” is a biopic about cinematic amphetamines. At times the film can feel like a long “Saturday Night Live” sketch played straight. But it’s like an “SNL” sketch shot and edited by Scorsese. The film parades in a barrage of narrative strategies: mock documentary interviews, scenes in which Madden (in an early version of his famous telestrator) diagrams football matches directly on the screen, all embellished with tasty drops of period needles (“How Long”, “Evil Ways”) performed in the jukebox-shuffle mode of “Casino”. John Madden was a football genius, but his games are pretty easy to follow because most of them are based on a chess-like simulation – making the opposing team’s players believe that This is strategy, when strategy is, in fact, the exact opposite of that.
“Madden” introduces another stylized semi-prosthetic character: Oakland Raiders owner Al Davis, played by Christian Bale with a shark mouth and straight, receding hairline, a Jewish goombah accent and a doll-princess wife (an unrecognizable Sienna Miller), all of which makes you think he must be some kind of vicious criminal. But no, Davis is just Madden’s monomaniacal comrade (Madden’s relentless football artist businessman), and these two have an uneasy friendship even once Madden leaves the team.
Moving forward in an attention-deficit rush, “Madden” keeps you watching, but it also keeps you at arm’s length. It’s a fun, quirky genre film that will appeal to sports fanatics, perhaps especially sports fanatics of a certain age. In theaters (where it released modestly), I suspect the film will be doomed to failure. But I could see it becoming a streaming success, and for the right reasons: In its skewed way, “Madden” is a film crafted out of obsession. And it’s Cage’s performance that brings this to life. His Madden is OCD about football – he lives to diagram plays, to outsmart the other team, to win. But his football madness is so all-consuming that it threatens to overturn his marriage to Virginia (Kathryn Hahn), his supportive but loving wife, who only wants him to be there. But he cannot be present; not really. He lives in his footballer’s head.
Cage captures the manic side of Madden, the arrested sports fetishist, the one who lived in a state of chronic disorder (his clothes don’t fit him, even his hair doesn’t suit him). But the one Cage trait you can’t hide are those hurt, sensitive puppy dog eyes — the ones he’s been flashing at audiences since “Valley Girl.” There is an inner softness to Nicolas Cage and, ironically, that is also the quality of John Madden. He was training a team of infamous thugs, and he was shouting from the sidelines; at CBS, he barked out his gaming theories like a sportsman loosening his leash. He could have been the model for Fred Willard’s deranged color commentator in “Best in Show.” Yet he also had a strangely innocent quality. Madden was an overgrown kid – a sports fanatic who never grew up. The film’s joke – its theme, in fact – is that it recognizes what a dysfunctional state of being it is, but it also presents Madden’s football spirit as a vulgarly American state of grace.
It’s been a long time since we heard the filming voice by David O. Russell. His last film, “Amsterdam” (2022), was a convoluted disaster, and his film before that, the just-released “Joy,” was released in 2015. It had its own fall from grace (those angry videos on the “I Heart Huckabees” set!), and quite a fall from the seething glory days of “Silver Linings Playbook” and “American Hustle.” But let’s not underestimate it: these were fantastic films that confirmed Russell’s status as a major American cinematic artist. “Madden” isn’t close to being in their league, but it’s crafted just well enough to let you hit the buzz of Russell’s intelligence, his attraction to scruffy bad behavior and his joy in filming.
The film is divided into three sections, with the first taking place during Madden’s moment of total triumph in football: the 1976 season, when he led the Raiders to victory in the AFC Championship Game and then beat the Pittsburgh Steelers in the Super Bowl. It was Madden’s only Super Bowl victory — but perhaps more importantly, it was the only time his Raiders won the AFC, even though he led them season after season. They were a team as cursed as the Boston Red Sox, and “Madden” delves into that pessimistic karma by dramatizing the way it tears Madden’s home life apart. In 1979, he suffered from a bleeding ulcer and Virginia no longer participated in competitive football. The only way for him to save his marriage is to retire from coaching (although Al Davis will continue to try to win him back).
The second part of the film chronicles Madden’s entry into CBS Sports, a comedy of errors that is also a game-changing comedy of triumph. His chatty analysis, punctuated with “Wham!” and “Boom!” ” is a crude imposition on the orderly play of Pat Summerall (Joel Murray). But it’s Madden who knows the game, who has the ideas, who makes sports announcements exciting.
The wild card of “Madden” – because you wouldn’t even expect it to be part of a biopic – is all the time the film devotes to Trip Hawkins (an eagle-eyed John Mulaney), the founder of Electronic Arts, the pioneering video game company. He understood early on that Madden’s playbook could become the heart of a visionary digital interactive experience. Hawkins wants to turn football into a video game, but the way to make it great is to feature Madden’s plays, which Madden keeps at home in an overstuffed binder he calls The Book. This is the ultimate treasure trove of strategic football magic tricks. Watching the stubbornly analog Madden try to adapt to the concept of squeezing the football on a computer screen becomes a hilarious and touching metaphor for how our entire culture has become a potato by proxy.
The Madden we see is also a couch potato. He is the apotheosis of the football coach: that angry, roly-poly American archetype (Lombardi, Shula, Schembechler) who is a former mediocre athlete and now operates strictly from the neck down. Madden becomes a celebrity, a pitchman for everything from Miller Lite to Tinactin, and he puts the turducken on the map – that mass of fowl that’s part turkey, part duck, part chicken. “Madden” is a real movie, a football saga stuffed with domestic geek romance wrapped in a Wikipedia biopic about Scorsese’s stimulants. What’s eye-catching is that it stays true to John Madden – how uncool he was and how it was that very quality that made him football’s overlooked Buddha.
Gn entert